---
title: "Wars in the name of Christianity: a sourced compilation"
date: 2026-11-18
kind: research
provenance: derived
authors: ["Claude deep-research run (Claude Opus 5.5)", "Adam Blvck (question)"]
summary: A tiered, source-graded compilation of 135 wars, campaigns and armed episodes fought or justified in the name of Christianity from 312 to November 2026, giving for each the Christian link, casualty ranges with labelled sources, and the main scholarly disputes.
keywords: [Christianity, holy war, crusades, just war theory, wars of religion, Reconquista, Northern Crusades, Albigensian Crusade, colonial conquest, Doctrine of Discovery, religious violence, casualty estimates, source criticism, Russian Orthodox Church, Lord's Resistance Army]
---

# Sixteen centuries of wars waged under the cross

**Executive summary.** This compilation identifies **135 wars, campaigns and armed episodes** between 312 and November 2026 in which Christianity or Christ was invoked as cause, licence or banner, and grades each by the strength of that link and the quality of the evidence. **Seventy-one reach Tier 1**, holy war in the strict sense: war authorised or explicitly justified in Christ's name, usually with spiritual rewards or conversion aims. That count is swollen by the many discrete campaigns of one institution: 45 of the 71 are crusades between 1095 and 1699, 12 are colonial conquests licensed by papal bulls or providential preaching, 9 precede 1095 and only 5 fall after 1900. Holy war of this kind is overwhelmingly a Latin Christian creation, foreshadowed by 9th-century papal letters, launched by Urban II in 1095, turned on pagans, heretics and the papacy's Christian rivals, and written into Iberian title to the Americas, while the Byzantine church refused it outright. A further **26 are Tier 2 confessional wars** between Christians, clustered between the 1520s and 1712; the deadliest, the Thirty Years' War, killed about **5 million**, yet its leading modern historian denies it was a religious conflict. After 1900 most "Christian" conflicts (18 Tier 3 cases overall) use the faith as a communal banner over land and nationhood, a few remain explicitly theological (the Cristeros, Spain's episcopal "Crusade", the Lord's Resistance Army, US anti-abortion bombers), and the **Russian Orthodox Church's 2024 decree calling the invasion of Ukraine a "Holy War"** is the clearest live case in 2026. Casualty claims are the weakest part of the record: chroniclers inflated by up to an order of magnitude, the popular **1 to 9 million crusade death toll has no scholarly basis**, and the largest mortality tied to Christian expansion (about **55 million** in the 16th-century Americas) was driven mainly by epidemic disease amplified by conquest. Christians fought on both sides in 28 entries, and the warrant for war was contested from inside Christianity at every stage, from early church orders that barred soldiers from killing to Las Casas, the Anabaptists, the Quakers and the Vatican's 2023 repudiation of the Doctrine of Discovery.

## How the compilation was built and graded

The report synthesises eleven research-note files: seven first-pass files covering late antiquity to the present, theology and historiography, and four gap-fill files that add conflicts and, in places, correct the first pass. Every claim below traces to a page the researchers actually fetched; Wikipedia was used as a pointer and is labelled weak wherever it carries a claim alone. Where notes conflict, the later gap notes and the higher-quality source win, and the conflict is stated. **Scope** follows the question's wording: a conflict qualifies when at least one belligerent, or the authority licensing it, invoked Christianity or Christ as cause, sanction or banner. Three adjacent categories are included but flagged because they explain the record: coercion campaigns that were not wars (the Serapeum, the Goa Inquisition), anti-Christian risings provoked by Christian coercion (the Pueblo Revolt, the Boxers), and conflicts where a Christian label was attached by outsiders and is disputed (Biafra, Tigray). Wars between Christian states fought without religious framing are excluded.

### The 4-label source quality check

Every source in the bibliography, and every inline citation, carries one of four labels. The label rates the *source*; it does not certify every sentence in it.

| Label | Definition | How to read it |
|---|---|---|
| **[P] Primary** | Contemporary record: decrees, bulls, chronicles, letters, court records, manifestos, official statements, or a faithful translation of one | Shows what was said or believed. Numbers, miracles and atrocity tallies in it still need checking |
| **[S] Scholarly** | Peer-reviewed article, university-press book, or work by a recognised historian (including reviews by specialists) | Expert judgement; disagreements between specialists are reported |
| **[R] Reference** | Major encyclopedias, museums, government, NGO or UN material, reputable journalism, university explainers | Good for orientation and standard facts; key claims should trace to [S] or [P] |
| **[W] Weak / unverified** | Wikipedia-only, blogs, advocacy or partisan outlets, AI-assisted translations, search-result titles not opened ("title-level") | Never sufficient alone. A claim resting only on [W] is marked **[W-only]** |

Three reading rules apply throughout. First, a claim supported only by [W] sources is flagged **[W-only]** in the text and listed again in the unverified section. Second, where figures conflict, the report shows a range and labels each source, rather than picking a number. Third, a genuine [P] source can be a reliable witness to belief and an unreliable witness to numbers; this follows the intelligence practice of rating a source and its information separately ([Wikipedia, Admiralty code](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Admiralty_code) [W]) and the library CRAAP test of currency, relevance, authority, accuracy and purpose ([CSU Chico, CRAAP test](https://library.csuchico.edu/sites/default/files/craap-test.pdf) [R]). Two judgement calls: the blog of crusade historian Andrew Holt is labelled [W] by format, although it summarises checkable scholarship; Medievalists.net reprints of peer-reviewed work are labelled [S], its original popular essays [R]. The master table gives each conflict an **overall rating**: the best label supporting the core claim that Christianity was invoked.

### Four tiers for the strength of the Christian link

| Tier | Definition | Typical cases |
|---|---|---|
| **T1 Holy war / crusade** | Authorised or explicitly justified in Christ's name as the war's purpose: indulgences, remission of sins, conversion or defence of the faith as stated aims. Sub-types noted as "popular", "heterodox" or "individual" where no church authority sanctioned it | Crusades, Saxon wars, Spanish conquest under the bulls, Taiping, LRA, ROC 2024 decree |
| **T2 Confessional war** | Christians against Christians over doctrine or church order, with religion intertwined with state power | Hussite Wars, French Wars of Religion, Thirty Years' War, Covenanters |
| **T3 Communal or ethnic banner** | "Christian" chiefly labels a community fighting over land, power or nationhood; religious reading contested | Lebanon, Northern Ireland, Bosnia, anti-balaka, Nigeria's Middle Belt |
| **T4 Rhetoric or symbolism only** | Christianity appears as sign, civilisational marker or later legend, not as a documented war aim | Milvian Bridge, Tours 732, Crimean War, Breivik, Bush's "crusade" |

Two flags qualify the tiers. **AC** marks a conflict that was partly or mainly *anti-Christian* (a reaction to Christian coercion or a persecution of Christians). **BS** marks a conflict in which Christians fought on *both sides*, including crusades declared against Christian targets. Tiers rate only the link to Christianity; they say nothing about a war's morality or scale.

### Corrections applied from the gap-fill notes

The gap-fill research corrected several first-pass claims, and the corrected versions are used throughout. **Vox in Rama** (June 1233) targeted alleged "Luciferian" heretics in the Rhineland and is not the Stedinger crusade bull; the crusade was authorised by *Lucis eterne lumine* (29 October 1232) ([Wikipedia, Stedinger Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stedinger_Crusade) [W]). **Jasenovac** deaths are given as **77,000-99,000** from the US Holocaust Memorial Museum, replacing the earlier 56,000-97,000 from a secondary page ([USHMM, Jasenovac](https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/jasenovac) [R]). ***Quantum praedecessores*** dates to **1 December 1145** ([WHE, Second Crusade](https://www.worldhistory.org/Second_Crusade/) [R]); the Fordham page header's "1154" is a transposition. The widely repeated claim that **123 of 1,763 wars** in Phillips and Axelrod's *Encyclopedia of Wars* were religious is an index-heading count (121 entries, about 6.9%) popularised by the polemicist Vox Day (Theodore Beale), not a classification by the editors ([Holt, Counting religious wars](https://apholt.com/2018/12/26/counting-religious-wars-in-the-encyclopedia-of-wars/) [W]). John Paul II's **Day of Pardon homily of 12 March 2000 does not name the crusades** ([Vatican, homily of 12 March 2000](https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/homilies/2000/documents/hf_jp-ii_hom_20000312_pardon.html) [P]). Smaller corrections: the 1683 siege of Vienna ran 17 July to 12 September; the 3,000 figure for Jerusalem in 1099 belongs to Ibn al-ʿArabī as analysed by Hirschler, not to Kedar; Pius II died on 14 or 15 August 1464; the *Requerimiento* reading was abolished in 1556 by one verified source, while the 1573 Ordinances banned the word "conquest"; and two Moscow Times articles with 2026 URLs carry February 2025 content.


## From soldiers barred from killing to remission of sins for killing

The theological arc runs through three distinct stages, each contested from within: a reluctant early church, Augustine's just war with its licence to coerce heretics, and the Latin invention of penitential holy war between the 9th and 12th centuries. A parallel counter-tradition never disappeared.

### The early church was reluctant and divided

The *Apostolic Tradition* attributed to Hippolytus (Rome, late 2nd century) ruled that "a soldier of the government must be told not to execute men", told such soldiers to refuse orders to kill and turned would-be volunteers away; Tertullian's *De Corona* argued that Christians could not bear the sword, and Origen conceded that Christians did not defend the empire by arms while claiming their prayers did more good. Yet inscriptions show soldiers in the church by about 200, and refusals of service on Christian grounds (Maximilian, the centurion Marcellus) are recorded in the 3rd and 4th centuries ([Davis 1949, Blackfriars](https://core-prod.cambridgecore.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/DEAEEA0F8147AE09FB1AF8283D9BB066/S1754201400034809a.pdf/the-early-christian-attitude-to-war.pdf) [S]). Tertullian himself had earlier answered charges of disloyalty by saying Christians served in the army, and J. Daryl Charles disputes John Howard Yoder's reading of a uniformly negative pre-Constantinian answer ([First Things, Anderson 2010](https://firstthings.com/were-the-church-fathers-pacifists/) [W]). The defensible summary is **predominantly reluctant and ambivalent**, which is weaker than "pacifist".

### Augustine supplied the criteria and the licence to coerce

Augustine (d. 430) held that a soldier acting under legitimate authority is an instrument of that authority and not personally guilty, and that wars fought at divine command do not breach the commandment against killing ([IEP, Just War Theory](https://iep.utm.edu/justwar/) [R]). Aquinas later preserved his definition of a just war as one that avenges wrongs and his insistence that cruelty and lust for domination are what make war sinful ([Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II q.40](https://www.newadvent.org/summa/3040.htm) [P]). Equally consequential for this compilation was Augustine's theology of coercion. In Letter 93 (408) he admits he once thought no one should be forced into Catholic unity and was persuaded otherwise by results, noting that his own town came over through fear of imperial edicts ([Augustine, Letter 93](https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1102093.htm) [P]). In Letter 185 he applies Luke 14:23, "compel them to come in", to heretics and schismatics ([Augustine, Letter 185](https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1102185.htm) [P]). That patristic warrant later underwrote crusades against heretics.

### Canon law turned tolerance into doctrine

Gratian's *Decretum* (c. 1140, Causa 23) concluded that warfare itself was not sinful, placed the blame on cruelty and the desire to dominate, and defined a just war as one waged by public authority to avenge injuries, without specifying which authorities or injuries qualify ([Winroth 2022, Cambridge History of Medieval Canon Law](https://core-prod.cambridgecore.org/core/books/cambridge-history-of-medieval-canon-law/just-war-and-crusades/8C78979F9E5A6D07D5EE89FF3F546E07) [S]). Aquinas (c. 1270) fixed three conditions, sovereign authority, just cause and right intention, and ruled that clerics may give spiritual help but must not fight ([Aquinas, ST II-II q.40](https://www.newadvent.org/summa/3040.htm) [P]); his framework became the model for Francisco de Vitoria's treatment of the peoples of the Americas ([IEP](https://iep.utm.edu/justwar/) [R]). The canonists split over whether non-Christians could legitimately hold property and rule: scholars long read the 1513 *Requerimiento* as reflecting Hostiensis's denial of infidel dominium, while Las Casas and Vitoria followed his teacher, Pope Innocent IV, who recognised it ([Muldoon 1980, The Americas](https://cambridge.org/core/journals/americas/article/john-wyclif-and-the-rights-of-the-infidels-the-requerimiento-reexamined/0D2712477AA1CD583F34DC6CC9D0235C) [S]).

### Sacralised war became penitential holy war

The Peace of God movement (Le Puy 975, Charroux c. 989) protected clergy, pilgrims, merchants and other non-combatants, and Britannica credits it with fostering a "sacred militancy" that prepared the way for the crusades ([Britannica, Peace of God](https://www.britannica.com/topic/Peace-of-God) [R]). Carl Erdmann's classic study traces the Western church's move from aversion to armed combat towards "a war whose specific cause was religion", stressing the reform papacy of Gregory VII ([Princeton UP, Erdmann](https://press.princeton.edu/node/6288) [S]); Latham describes the crusade as a fusion of three strands: holy war against heretics and pagans, a just war whose authority canonists reserved to the pope, and penance, which let knights atone without abandoning arms ([Latham 2025, Medievalists.net](https://www.medievalists.net/2025/07/how-the-crusade-became-a-medieval-institution/) [R]). The documentary precedents are concrete. Leo IV (c. 850, date variously 848-853) promised Frankish troops fighting Saracens that "the kingdom of heaven will be given as a reward" to those killed, and John VIII in 878 promised eternal life and absolution, as far as permissible, to those dying against pagans ([Colorado War and Society Sourcebook](https://colorado.pressbooks.pub/warandsocietysourcebook/chapter/pre-crusades-forgiveness-of-sin-for-fighting-wars/) [P]). Alexander II in late 1063 lifted the penance of those going to fight in Spain and granted remission of sins ([Ott, Letters of Alexander II](https://web.pdx.edu/~ott/hst399/Alexanderletters) [P]). At Clermont on 18 November 1095 Urban II's canons granted remission of all penance to those aiding Eastern Christians ([Britannica, Crusades](https://www.britannica.com/event/Crusades) [R]); the chronicle versions of his speech, all written after the capture of Jerusalem, inflate this into "immediate remission of sins" (Fulcher), and only Robert the Monk records the cry *Deus vult* ([Fordham, Urban II five versions](https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/urban2-5vers.asp) [P]). Bernard of Clairvaux's treatise for the Templars (c. 1136) gave the doctrine its sharpest rhetoric: the knight of Christ who kills a pagan is "a killer of evil" rather than a mankiller ([Bernard, De laude novae militiae, ORB](https://www.the-orb.arlima.net/encyclop/religion/monastic/bernard.html) [P]). The Third Lateran Council (1179) extended indulgences to war against heretics and the Fourth (1215) codified crusade privileges, a claim resting here on **[W-only]** sourcing ([Wikipedia, Crusading movement](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusading_movement) [W]).

### Byzantium refused to make holy war

The Eastern church is the decisive comparison. When Nikephoros II Phokas asked in the 960s that soldiers killed fighting Muslims be proclaimed martyrs, Patriarch Polyeuktos refused, citing St Basil's canon that barred those who had shed blood from communion for three years ([Morris 1988, BMGS](https://cambridge.org/core/journals/byzantine-and-modern-greek-studies/article/two-faces-of-nikephoros-phokas/606BB35357FFB37017D1E97ADDB9F122) [S]). Byzantinists describe a religiously coloured just war that resembled holy war without matching it, and Walter Kaegi calls it "an exaggeration" to describe Heraclius' strategy as holy war ([Vienna, Byzantinische Kriegsideologie abstracts](https://byzneo.univie.ac.at/fileadmin/user_upload/i_byzneo/Plakate_und_Programme/Abstracts_Kriegsideologie.pdf) [S]). Holy war with spiritual rewards is therefore a specifically Latin development.

### A counter-tradition contested the warrant at every stage

Opposition ran alongside every phase. Alcuin urged Charlemagne's circle that instruction must precede baptism and faith cannot be compelled, though the only translation retrieved is AI-assisted ([romanletters.org, Alcuin Letter 7](https://romanletters.org/letters/alcuin_york/7/) [W]). In September 1219 Francis of Assisi crossed the lines at Damietta to preach to Sultan al-Kamil; John Tolan stresses that almost nothing is known of what was said, and that later writers recast Francis variously as crusader, missionary and "medieval Gandhi" ([Tolan 2008, via Medievalists.net](https://www.medievalists.net/2012/10/the-friar-and-the-sultan-francis-of-assisis-mission-to-egypt/) [S]). At the Council of Constance (1415) the Polish canonist Paulus Vladimiri argued that pagans had a right to peace and to their lands, attacking the Teutonic Order's wars ([Wikipedia, Paweł Włodkowic](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pawe%C5%82_W%C5%82odkowic) [W]). Erasmus published *Dulce bellum inexpertis* (1515) and *Querela Pacis* (1517) ([FU Berlin, Erasmus exhibition catalogue](https://refubium.fu-berlin.de/bitstream/handle/fub188/35224/Erasmus%20-%20%27War%20is%20sweet%20to%20those%20who%20have%20no%20experience%20of%20it%20%E2%80%A6%27%20-%20Protest%20against%20Violence%20and%20War.pdf) [R]). The Anabaptist Schleitheim Confession (1527) held that "the sword is ordained of God outside the perfection of Christ" and barred Christians from bearing it ([Schleitheim Confession](https://anabaptists.org/history/schleith.html) [P]). Dominicans in Hispaniola (1511) and Las Casas at Valladolid (1550-51) attacked the conquest's Christian justifications on Christian grounds (see the colonial section). George Fox and eleven other Quakers told Charles II they "utterly deny, with all outward wars and strife" ([Quaker Declaration to Charles II](https://quaker.org/legacy/minnfm/peace/A%20Declaration%20to%20Charles%20II%201660.htm) [P]). Modern acts of contrition are real but narrower than often reported: John Paul II's 2000 homily asked pardon for "the violence some have used in the service of the truth" without naming the crusades ([Vatican, homily of 12 March 2000](https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/homilies/2000/documents/hf_jp-ii_hom_20000312_pardon.html) [P]), and the 2023 Joint Note repudiated the Doctrine of Discovery while declining to rescind the bulls (colonial section). In April 2024 the World Council of Churches said it could not reconcile the Russian church's "Holy War" decree with Christian teaching, a point attested here only at headline level ([Vatican News, WCC statement](https://vaticannews.va/en/world/news/2024-04/wcc-russia-decree-war-ukraine-statement.html) [W]).


## Master table: 135 conflicts graded by link and evidence

Casualty cells show ranges with the label of each source; "no figure" means none was found in a fetched source. The rating column gives the best label supporting the core claim that Christianity was invoked. Numbers in the first column are used for cross-reference in the era sections.

| # | Conflict | Dates | Region | Tier | Christian link | Casualties (labelled) | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| | **Late antiquity and early Middle Ages** | | | | | | |
| 1 | Battle of the Milvian Bridge | 312 | Italy | T4 | Chi-Rho or labarum in later Christian accounts | No reliable figure | R |
| 2 | Constantine vs Licinius (Chrysopolis) | 324 | Bosporus | T4 | Labarum against pagan standards (Eusebius) | 25,000-30,000 Licinian dead [W]; Zosimus 100,000, called exaggerated [W] | W |
| 3 | Destruction of the Serapeum (coercion, not war) | 391 | Alexandria | T1 | Imperial anti-pagan law; patriarch-provoked riot | No figure | R |
| 4 | Donatist and Circumcellion conflict, imperial coercion | c. 317-420s | North Africa | T2 / BS | Augustine's case for compelling schismatics | No figure | P |
| 5 | Battle of the Frigidus | 394 | Julian Alps | T4 / BS | Providential wind; pagan label added later | c. 10,000 Gothic allies on day one [W-only] | S |
| 6 | Clovis vs Alamanni; Vouillé | c. 496/506; 507 | Gaul | T2 | Conversion vow; war on Arians (Gregory of Tours) | No figure | P |
| 7 | Justinian's Vandal War | 533-534 | North Africa | T2 (contested) | Liberation of Catholics from Arian rule | No figure | S |
| 8 | Justinian's Gothic War | 535-554 | Italy | T2 (contested) | Arian Goths; no explicit anti-Arian aim found | Italy devastated; no figure [W] | W |
| 9 | Kaleb of Axum vs Himyar | c. 520-525 | Yemen | T1 | Avenging persecuted Najran Christians | No figure | W |
| 10 | Heraclius vs Sasanian Persia | 602-628 | Near East | T4 (contested) | Recovery of the True Cross | No figure | R |
| 11 | Covadonga | 722 | Asturias | T4 | Later Reconquista founding story | Slaughter (Christian accounts) vs skirmish (Umayyad) [W] | W |
| 12 | Tours/Poitiers | 732 | Gaul | T4 | Later saved-Christendom framing | c. 10,000 Muslim, <1,000 Frankish, unsourced [R] | R |
| 13 | Charlemagne's Saxon wars (Verden) | 772-804 | Saxony | T1 | Death penalty for avoiding baptism | Verden 782: 4,500 executed per annals [W quoting P]; disputed | P |
| 14 | Charlemagne's Avar wars | 788-803 | Pannonia | T1 | Fasting and litanies; 796 synod on baptism | No figure | W |
| 15 | Papal wars against Saracens (Leo IV, John VIII) | c. 846-882 | Italy | T1 | Heaven and absolution for the fallen | No figure | P |
| 16 | Clavijo (legendary) | 844 | Rioja | T4 | St James Matamoros legend, first attested c. 1243 | Legendary | W |
| 17 | Nikephoros II's eastern wars | 961-969 | Crete, Cilicia, Syria | T4 | Martyr status for soldiers requested and refused | No figure | S |
| 18 | Ottonian conquest of the Wends; Slav revolt | 948-983 | Elbe region | T1 / AC | Bishoprics imposed; pagan rising destroyed them | No figure | W |
| 19 | Vladimir: Chersonesos and baptism of Rus' | 987-989 | Crimea, Rus' | T1 | Forced baptism by fire and sword (later chronicle) | No figure | W |
| 20 | Hungary (Koppány, Vata) and Poland's pagan reaction | 997-1046 | Hungary, Poland | T3 / AC | Dynastic wars on a pagan-Christian divide | No figure | W |
| 21 | Christianisation of Norway; Stiklestad | 995-1030 | Norway | T1 / BS | Forced conversion; Christ's men war cry; both armies Christian | Saga figures 3,500 vs 13,000, unreliable [R] | R |
| 22 | Siege of Barbastro | 1063-1064 | Aragon | T1 (contested) | Alexander II's remission of sins for Spain | 50,000 claim vs <8,000 inhabitants [W] | P |
| | **Eastern crusades and anti-Ottoman wars** | | | | | | |
| 23 | People's Crusade and Rhineland pogroms | 1096 | Rhineland, Anatolia | T1 | Vengeance for the crucifixion; convert or die | Mainz c. 1,100 (chronicler) [P] | P |
| 24 | First Crusade (Jerusalem 1099) | 1095-1099 | Anatolia, Syria, Palestine | T1 | Remission of sins; Holy Sepulchre | Jerusalem c. 3,000 [S] to c. 10,000 [P]; 70,000-100,000 later inflation [S] | P |
| 25 | Crusade of 1101 | 1101 | Anatolia | T1 | Papal reinforcement crusade | Collapsed; no figure | R |
| 26 | Bohemond's crusade | 1107-1108 | Dyrrhachium | T1 / BS | Papally backed attack on Byzantium | No figure | R |
| 27 | Norwegian Crusade | 1107-1111 | Levant | T1 | Royal crusade; Sidon | No figure | R |
| 28 | Venetian Crusade | 1122-1124 | Levant | T1 | Crusade with commercial reward; Tyre | No figure | R |
| 29 | Second Crusade (incl. Lisbon) | 1145-1149 | Anatolia, Syria, Iberia | T1 | *Quantum praedecessores*; Bernard's preaching | Army 60,000, heavy losses, low reliability [R] | P |
| 30 | Third Crusade | 1189-1192 | Levant | T1 | Recovery of Jerusalem after 1187 | Acre 1191: c. 2,700 prisoners executed [R] | R |
| 31 | Fourth Crusade | 1202-1204 | Zara, Constantinople | T1 / BS | Crusade diverted onto Christian cities | No figure | P |
| 32 | Children's Crusade | 1212 | France, Germany | T1 (popular) | Unsanctioned crusade vows | None reached the East; no figure | R |
| 33 | Fifth Crusade | 1217-1221 | Egypt | T1 | Lateran IV blueprint; Damietta | No figure | R |
| 34 | Sixth Crusade | 1228-1229 | Levant | T1 | Excommunicate emperor regains Jerusalem by treaty | Negotiated; no figure | R |
| 35 | Barons' Crusade and La Forbie | 1239-1244 | Levant | T1 | Gains by truce, lost at La Forbie | La Forbie: over 1,000 knights, unsourced [R] | S |
| 36 | Seventh Crusade | 1248-1254 | Egypt | T1 | Louis IX's crusade | c. 18,000 sailed; army largely destroyed [R] | R |
| 37 | Shepherds' Crusades | 1251; 1320 | France, Aragon | T1 (popular) | Crusade fervour turned on clergy, Jews, lepers | 1320: 110 Jewish communities destroyed [R]; c. 2,000 Pastoureaux died [R] | R |
| 38 | Eighth Crusade and Lord Edward's Crusade | 1270-1272 | Tunis, Acre | T1 | Louis IX's last crusade | c. 1,000 lost in a storm [R] | R |
| 39 | Fall of Acre | 1291 | Levant | T1 (defensive) | End of the crusader mainland | Massacre and enslavement; no total [R] | R |
| 40 | Smyrniote crusades | 1343-1351 | Aegean | T1 | Bull *Insurgentibus contra fidem* | No figure | S |
| 41 | Alexandrian Crusade | 1365 | Egypt | T1 | Crusade as raid; sack and massacre | No figure | R |
| 42 | Savoyard Crusade | 1366-1367 | Gallipoli, Bulgaria | T1 / BS | Urban V's call against the Turks | No figure | R |
| 43 | Mahdia Crusade | 1390 | Tunisia | T1 | Recognised by both Schism popes | No figure | W |
| 44 | Crusade of Nicopolis | 1396 | Bulgaria | T1 | Western coalition against Bayezid I | Most captives executed; no figure [R] | R |
| 45 | Crusade of Varna | 1443-1444 | Bulgaria | T1 | Truce broken at the papal legate's urging | Army nearly annihilated [R] | R |
| 46 | Siege of Belgrade | 1456 | Serbia | T1 | Capistrano's crusaders; papal noon-bell bull | Forces only: c. 27,000 crusaders + 12,000 royal vs >60,000 [S] | S |
| 47 | Pius II's crusade | 1463-1464 | Ancona | T1 | Pope takes the cross | Collapsed before sailing | R |
| 48 | Holy League and Lepanto | 1571 | Ionian Sea | T1 | Papal alliance against the Ottomans | c. 8,000 dead per side; c. 15,000 slaves freed [R] | R |
| 49 | Vienna and the Holy League of 1684 | 1683-1699 | Central Europe, Balkans | T1 | Papal subsidy and leadership | No figure | R |
| | **Crusades within Europe** | | | | | | |
| 50 | Wendish Crusade | 1147 | Elbe, Baltic | T1 | Conversion or destruction (Bernard) | No figure | P |
| 51 | Livonian Crusade, Sword Brothers | c. 1193-1290 | Latvia, Estonia | T1 | Holy Land indulgence for one year's service | Chronicle claims only [W] | R |
| 52 | Prussian Crusade, Teutonic Order | 1217-1283 | Prussia | T1 | Papal and imperial bulls; conversion by conquest | Near-extermination of Prussians [R] vs assimilation reading [W] | R |
| 53 | Lithuanian Crusade and Grunwald | 1283-1422 | Lithuania, Poland | T1 / BS after 1387 | *Reisen*; war continued on a converted state | Grunwald: 8,000 (envoys) to 18,000 (1412 bull) [W] | R |
| 54 | Swedish crusades to Finland | 1150s?-1295 | Finland, Karelia | T1 (contested) | Legend and later chronicle propaganda | No figure | W |
| 55 | Crusades against Novgorod (Neva, Lake Peipus) | 1240-1242 | NW Russia | T1 (contested) / BS | Bulls name pagans, not Russians | 20 brothers (Rhymed Chronicle) vs 400 Germans (Novgorod) [W] | W |
| 56 | Las Navas de Tolosa and the military orders | 1158-1212 | Castile, Andalusia | T1 | Innocent III's crusade call; orders vowed to fight Muslims | c. 2,000 Christian, c. 20,000 Almohad est. [W]; chronicles 60,000-100,000 [W] | R |
| 57 | Granada War | 1482-1492 | Andalusia | T1 | Crusade-bull funding; later forced conversion | 100,000 dead or enslaved, unsourced [W] | R |
| 58 | Albigensian Crusade (to Montségur) | 1209-1244 | Languedoc | T1 / BS | First crusade against heretics inside Christendom | Béziers: legate's 20,000 vs city ≤10,000 [W]; totals of 200,000-1 million unsupported [W] | S |
| 59 | Drenther Crusade | 1228-1232 | Drenthe | T1 / BS | Rebels branded heretics; bull lost | No figure | W |
| 60 | Stedinger Crusade | 1229-1234 | Lower Weser | T1 / BS | Unsubstantiated heresy charge | Altenesch 2,000-11,000 (chronicles) [W] | R |
| 61 | Bosnian Crusade | 1235-1241 | Bosnia | T1 / BS | Heresy charge; Hungarian suzerainty | No figure | W |
| 62 | Crusades against Frederick II and the Hohenstaufen | 1239-1268 | Italy, Germany | T1 / BS | Political crusade against an emperor | No figure | R |
| 63 | Aragonese Crusade | 1284-1285 | Catalonia | T1 / BS | Papal fief claim after the Sicilian Vespers | No figure | W |
| 64 | Crusade against the Colonna | 1297-1298 | Lazio | T1 / BS | Pope's crusade on rival cardinals | No figure | R |
| 65 | Crusade against Fra Dolcino | 1306-1307 | Piedmont | T1 / BS | Millenarian Apostolic Brethren | No figure | W |
| 66 | Despenser's Crusade | 1382-1383 | Flanders | T1 / BS | Schism crusade; besieged a city of its own obedience | No figure | W |
| 67 | Hussite Wars and five crusades | 1419-1434 | Bohemia | T1 vs T2 / BS | Crusade bull against Hussite programme | Czech population 2.8-3.4m (1400) to 1.5-1.85m (1526), not all war [W] | R |
| | **Reformation-era wars** | | | | | | |
| 68 | German Peasants' War | 1524-1525 | Germany | T2 | "God's law"; Twelve Articles; Müntzer | c. 100,000 [R] | R |
| 69 | Kappel Wars | 1529; 1531 | Switzerland | T2 | Reformed vs Catholic cantons; Zwingli killed | No figure | R |
| 70 | Münster Rebellion | 1534-1535 | Westphalia | T2 / BS | Anabaptist kingdom besieged by bishop and nobles | No figure | R |
| 71 | Count's Feud | 1534-1536 | Denmark | T2 | Listed among wars of religion | No figure | W |
| 72 | Pilgrimage of Grace | 1536 | Northern England | T2 | Defence of the monasteries | 220-250 executed [R] | R |
| 73 | Schmalkaldic War | 1546-1547 (1552) | Germany | T2 | Survival of Protestantism; papal subsidy | No figure | R |
| 74 | Prayer Book Rebellion | 1549 | Devon, Cornwall | T2 | Latin Mass; Banner of the Five Wounds | Disputed: small counts to 500-600 [W] | W |
| 75 | French Wars of Religion (St Bartholomew) | 1562-1598 | France | T2 | Catholic vs Huguenot | 2-4 million incl. disease [W]; c. 4 million [R]; 1572: c. 5,000 [S] (claims 2,000-70,000 [R]) | R |
| 76 | Eighty Years' War | 1568-1648 | Low Countries | T2 (partly) | Calvinist revolt against Catholic Spain | 100,000-500,000 [R]; 600,000-700,000 [W] | R |
| 77 | Desmond Rebellions | 1569-1583 | Munster | T2 | Defence of Catholicism; papal troops | Smerwick 1580: c. 600 [R]; famine, no figure | R |
| 78 | Anglo-Spanish War and the Armada | 1585-1604 | Atlantic | T2 | Papal deposition of Elizabeth; papal subsidy | Armada: about half of 30,000 men died [R] | P |
| 79 | Cologne War | 1583-1588 | Rhineland | T2 | Prince-archbishop turns Calvinist | No figure | W |
| 80 | Thirty Years' War | 1618-1648 | Central Europe | T2 (contested) | Defenestration of Prague; Edict of Restitution | c. 5 million [S]; 15-20% population loss [R]; 4-12 million [W] | P |
| 81 | Huguenot rebellions, La Rochelle | 1621-1629 | France | T2 | Huguenot towns against the crown | La Rochelle: three-quarters starved [R]; up to 100,000 overall [W] | R |
| 82 | Shimabara Rebellion | 1637-1638 | Japan | T3 / AC | Christian peasants against persecuting, taxing lords | c. 37,000 [R] | R |
| 83 | Bishops' Wars, Wars of the Three Kingdoms, 1641 and Confederate Ireland | 1639-1651 | British Isles | T2 | Prayer book, Covenant, Catholic restoration | Ireland 25-33% (Petty) to >40% (Carlton) [S]; 1641 settlers c. 4,000 vs 154,000 claimed [R] | P |
| 84 | Cromwellian conquest of Ireland (Drogheda) | 1649-1653 | Ireland | T2 | Massacre called God's judgement | Drogheda c. 2,000 (Cromwell) [P] | P |
| 85 | Villmergen Wars | 1656; 1712 | Switzerland | T2 | Catholic vs Reformed cantons | 1712: c. 4,000 dead and wounded [R] | R |
| 86 | Solovetsky Monastery siege | 1668-1676 | White Sea | T2 / BS | Old Believer monks vs reformed state church | Most monks killed [R] | R |
| 87 | Covenanter risings (Bothwell Bridge) | 1666-1679 | Scotland | T2 / BS | Presbyterians vs imposed episcopacy | Bothwell: c. 400 dead, 1,200 prisoners [R] | R |
| 88 | Williamite War in Ireland | 1689-1691 | Ireland | T2 (Irish dimension) | Catholic Jacobites vs Protestant Williamites | Aughrim: c. 7,000 Jacobites [R] | R |
| 89 | Camisard War | 1702-1710 | Cévennes | T2 | Prophet-led Huguenots; toleration refused | No total; hundreds of villages burned [R] | R |
| | **Colonial conquest and imperial wars** | | | | | | |
| 90 | Conquest of the Canary Islands | 1402-1496 | Atlantic | T1 | Crusade bulls of 1344-45 | Aguere 1494: c. 1,700 Guanches [W] | W |
| 91 | Ceuta and the Portuguese Atlantic raids | 1415-1450s | Morocco, West Africa | T1 | Crusade revival; bulls licensing enslavement | Ceuta massacre, no figure [R] | R |
| 92 | Spanish Caribbean (Hispaniola, Taíno) | 1492-1540s | Caribbean | T1 | *Inter caetera*; *Requerimiento* | 60,000 left by 1508 (Las Casas); 1492 estimates 100,000-8 million [W] | P |
| 93 | Conquest of the Aztec Empire | 1519-1521 | Mexico | T1 | Cross banners; idol destruction | No figure retrieved | R |
| 94 | Conquest of the Inca Empire (Cajamarca) | 1532-1530s | Peru | T1 | Valverde's summons and breviary | No figure retrieved | R |
| 95 | Maya conquest | c. 1517-1697 | Yucatán, Guatemala | T1 | Conquest, mission, Landa's book-burning | Heavy depopulation [R] | R |
| 96 | Mixtón War | 1540-1542 | Jalisco | T1 / AC | Spanish conquest vs anti-Christian rising | Thousands enslaved [W] | W |
| 97 | Chichimeca War | c. 1550-1590 | Northern Mexico | T1 (contested) | Total war (*a fuego y sangre*) debated by clergy | No figure | S |
| 98 | Philippines: Legazpi, Castilian War, Moro wars | 1565-1898 | Philippines, Borneo | T1 | Baptism as allegiance; demand to preach | 1578: 17 Spanish dead [W] | R |
| 99 | Ethiopian-Adal War | 1529-1543 | Ethiopia | T3 | Portuguese aid to a Christian kingdom against jihad | No figure | W |
| 100 | Russian conquest of Siberia | 1581-1778 | Siberia | T4 | Orthodoxy a secondary pretext to fur tribute | Disease-led declines [W] | W |
| 101 | Pequot War and King Philip's War | 1636-1676 | New England | T1 (informal) | Puritan *wars of the Lord* | Mystic 1637: 400-700 Pequots [S] | S |
| 102 | Kongo-Portugal war (Mbwila) | 1665 | Angola | T4 / BS | Catholic kingdom vs Catholic colony | >5,000 Kongolese soldiers [R] | R |
| 103 | Pueblo Revolt and reconquest | 1680-1692 | New Mexico | AC | Rising against forced Catholicism | c. 400 Spaniards incl. 21 priests [R] | R |
| 104 | Goa Inquisition (coercion, not war) | 1560-1812 | Goa | T1 | Temple destruction; heresy trials | 57 burned; 3,800-16,000 trials [W] | W |
| 105 | Greek War of Independence | 1821-1829 | Greece | T3 | Clergy exhortations; Orthodox vs Muslim | Tripolitsa 6,000-15,000; Chios up to 100,000 killed or enslaved [W] | W |
| 106 | Russo-Circassian War and expulsions | 1763-1878 | NW Caucasus | T3 | Orthodox messianism, Christianisation programme | 400,000-1.5 million [W] | W |
| 107 | Taiping Rebellion | 1850-1864 | China | T1 (heterodox) | Hong Xiuquan as Christ's younger brother | c. 20 million [R]; 20-30 million common [W] | R |
| 108 | Crimean War | 1853-1856 | Black Sea | T4 / BS | Holy Places dispute; Christians allied with Ottomans | c. 250,000 per side [R] | R |
| 109 | Russo-Turkish War | 1877-1878 | Balkans | T3 | Tsar as protector of Orthodox Christians | Russian losses up to 200,000 [W] | R |
| 110 | Buganda religious wars | 1888-1892 | Uganda | T2 / BS | Protestant, Catholic and Muslim factions | No figure | R |
| 111 | Mahdist War and Omdurman | 1881-1898 | Sudan | T4 | Gordon as Christian martyr; jihad state opposite | Omdurman: c. 10,000 Mahdists, 48 British [R] | R |
| 112 | Boxer Rebellion | 1899-1901 | China | AC | Rising against missionaries and converts | Up to 100,000+; 200-250 foreigners; thousands of Chinese Christians [R] | R |
| | **1900 to November 2026** | | | | | | |
| 113 | Cristero War | 1926-1929; 1934-1940 | Mexico | T1 (popular) / AC | "Christ the King" against an anticlerical state | c. 90,000 (Meyer) [R] | R |
| 114 | Iron Guard (Legion of the Archangel Michael) | 1927-1941 | Romania | T3 | Orthodox-mystical fascism | 1941 pogrom: c. 150 Jews [R] | R |
| 115 | Spanish Civil War | 1936-1939 | Spain | T1 (episcopal) / AC | Bishops' "Crusade"; anticlerical massacres | Almost 7,000 clergy and religious killed [W citing S] | W |
| 116 | Independent State of Croatia (Ustaše) | 1941-1945 | Croatia, Bosnia | T3 | Forced conversion of Orthodox Serbs | Serbs 320,000-340,000 [R] or 330,000-390,000 [R]; Jasenovac 77,000-99,000 [R] | R |
| 117 | Sudan civil wars | 1955-1972; 1983-2005 | Sudan | T3 | Christian and animist south vs Islamist state | 1983-2005: 1-2 million [S] | S |
| 118 | Nigeria-Biafra War | 1967-1970 | Nigeria | T4 | Religious framing as propaganda | 500,000-3 million [R] | S |
| 119 | Rhodesian Bush War | 1964-1979 | Rhodesia | T4 | Regime's "Christian civilisation" claim | No figure | S |
| 120 | The Troubles | 1969-1998 | Northern Ireland | T3 / BS | Catholic and Protestant communal labels | 3,532 (1969-2001) [R] | R |
| 121 | Ilaga and Mindanao violence | c. 1970-1971 | Philippines | T3 | Christian settler militia against Muslims | Manili 1971: >70 [R]; 518 in 21 massacres, one tally [W] | R |
| 122 | Lebanese Civil War | 1975-1990 | Lebanon | T3 / BS | Christian militias; intra-sect fighting | c. 150,000 [R]; Sabra and Shatila 460-2,000 [R] | R |
| 123 | NSCN, "Nagaland for Christ" | 1980-present (ceasefire 1997) | NE India | T3 | Christian-nationalist slogan in manifesto | No total retrieved | R |
| 124 | Holy Spirit Movement and Lord's Resistance Army | 1986-present | Uganda, DRC, South Sudan, CAR | T1 (syncretic, contested) | Spirit mediumship; Christian-Acholi blend | >100,000 killed; 60,000-100,000 children abducted [R] | R |
| 125 | Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict | 1988-2023 | South Caucasus | T3 | Christian and Muslim labels over territory | No figure retrieved | S |
| 126 | NLFT insurgency, Tripura | 1989-2024 | NE India | T3 | Alleged Baptist backing and forced conversion | No figure | W |
| 127 | Yugoslav wars (Bosnia) | 1991-1995 | Bosnia | T3 (contested) | "Christoslavism"; clergy blessing weapons | Bosnia ≥97,207 [R]; Srebrenica 7,000-8,000 [R] | S |
| 128 | US anti-abortion and Christian Identity violence | 1990s-2010s | USA | T1 (individual) | Scripture-based justification of bombing | No aggregate figure | P |
| 129 | Bush's "crusade" and the war on terror | 2001 | Global | T4 | One-word rhetoric, later regretted | n/a | R |
| 130 | Breivik attacks | 2011 | Norway | T4 | "Knights Templar"; cultural Christianity | 77 [R] | R |
| 131 | Anti-balaka militias | 2013-present | Central African Republic | T3 | Largely Christian militias against Muslims | 2013-14: 3,000-6,000 [R] | R |
| 132 | Nigeria's Middle Belt and US action | c. 2001-present; 2025 | Nigeria | T3 / T4 | Christian farming communities; US strikes framed as protecting Christians | 2016: c. 2,500 [R]; Jan-Mar 2018: 1,078 [R] | R |
| 133 | Christchurch mosque attacks | 2019 | New Zealand | T4 | Crusade and siege dates on rifles | 51 [R] | R |
| 134 | Tigray War | 2020-2022 | Ethiopia | T4 / BS | Orthodox on both sides; holy sites attacked | <100,000 to c. 600,000 [R] | R |
| 135 | Russia-Ukraine war and the Russian Orthodox Church | 2022-present | Ukraine | T1 (church sacralisation) / BS | 2024 "Holy War" decree; death said to wash away sins | Not retrieved | R |

**Reading the distribution.** Of the 135 entries, 71 are Tier 1, 26 Tier 2, 18 Tier 3 and 18 Tier 4, and 2 are anti-Christian risings listed for context; 6 more carry the anti-Christian flag alongside a tier, and 28 carry the both-sides flag. Tier 1 entries cluster between 1095 and 1550, Tier 2 between 1520 and 1712, and Tier 3 after 1900. By overall rating, 16 entries rest on a primary source for their core Christian link, 14 on scholarship, 76 on reference works and 29 on weak sources only; those 29 are the least secure part of the compilation.


## Late antiquity and the early Middle Ages: imperial victories rewritten as Christian ones

Before 1095 the Christian framing of war came mostly from clerical writers decades or centuries after the event, laid over Roman civil wars and royal state-building. The exceptions, where conversion or defence of Christians was a documented aim, are Charlemagne's Saxon laws, the forced baptisms in Rus' and Norway, and the 9th-century papal letters that first promised heaven to fallen soldiers.

**#1 Milvian Bridge (312), T4.** Lactantius, writing about 315, says Constantine was told in a dream to mark his soldiers' shields with the Chi-Rho; Eusebius's later *Life of Constantine* adds a cross in the sky and the labarum standard, while his earlier *Church History* has neither, and the sources disagree on shields versus standard. Constantine defeated Maxentius, who drowned when a pontoon bridge over the Tiber collapsed. No reliable casualty figure exists. Because the vision is absent from the earliest accounts, some scholars doubt it, and the genuineness of a pre-battle conversion is debated ([Britannica, Milvian Bridge](https://www.britannica.com/topic/Battle-of-Milvian-Bridge) [R]).

**#2 Constantine against Licinius (324), T4.** Licinius reportedly drew up under pagan standards and forbade attacks on the labarum, while Constantine prayed in his tent before Chrysopolis; Licinius surrendered and was later executed. Casualty claims run from 25,000-30,000 Licinian dead to Zosimus's 100,000, which is considered exaggerated ([Wikipedia, Battle of Chrysopolis](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Chrysopolis) [W]). **[W-only]**; the underlying primary text (Eusebius, *Life*, Book II) was not fetched.

**#3 The Serapeum (391), T1 coercion, not a war.** Theodosius I's February 391 ban on pagan worship was followed by a rescript to Egypt's officials. Patriarch Theophilus paraded cult objects in mockery, Christians died in the riot that followed, and Theodosius declared them martyrs, pardoned the pagan defenders and ordered the temple destroyed; the Serapis statue was axed and burned ([Encyclopaedia Romana, Serapeum](https://penelope.uchicago.edu/~grout/encyclopaedia_romana/greece/paganism/serapeum.html) [R]). The narrative rests on Rufinus, copied by later church historians; no casualty figures survive, and some scholars prefer 392.

**#4 Donatists and Circumcellions (c. 317-420s), T2 / BS.** Constantine's coercion of the schismatic Donatist church (317-321) failed; Constans exiled Donatus (347); after the Conference of Carthage (411) laws of 412 and 414 stripped Donatists of rights ([Britannica, Donatists](https://www.britannica.com/topic/Donatists) [R]). Augustine's Letter 185 defends state force, citing Circumcellion mutilation of Catholic clergy and their ritual suicides ([Augustine, Letter 185](https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1102185.htm) [P]). R. Pierce Beaver argued the Donatist name sheltered a social and economic revolt, though clerics led Circumcellion bands ([Beaver 1935, Church History](https://cambridge.org/core/journals/church-history/article/donatist-circumcellions/4A25F506BB2212BFBB64345EB369DD4D) [S]). No casualty figures exist.

**#5 Frigidus (394), T4 / BS.** Theodosius's eastern army with Gothic allies beat the western usurper Eugenius, himself nominally Christian, and his general Arbogast; some 10,000 Goths reportedly died on the first day ([Wikipedia, Battle of the Frigidus](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Frigidus) [W], **[W-only]** for the figure). Rufinus first branded Eugenius's side pagan and Ambrose first told of the decisive bora wind; Laura Marzo reads the wind as a stock motif of Theodosian propaganda tying the state to Catholicism ([Marzo 2020](https://www.ceeol.com/search/article-detail?id=927239) [S]), and Alan Cameron calls the pagan label an invention (via Wikipedia [W]).

**#6 Clovis (c. 496/506 and 507), T2.** Gregory of Tours, writing about 590, has Clovis vow baptism if Christ grants victory over the Alamanni, says over 3,000 of his army were baptised, and before Vouillé gives him the line "I take it very hard that these Arians hold part of the Gauls", with omens from the shrines of St Martin and St Hilary ([Gregory of Tours, Histories II, Fordham](https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/gregory-clovisconv.asp) [P]). The religious reading depends on one bishop writing 80 years later; the outcome at Vouillé was not confirmed in a fetched source.

**#7 Vandal War (533-534), T2 contested.** Justinian's reconquest was partly presented as freeing the African Catholic majority from Arian persecution, and Catholic clergy welcomed Byzantine rule in 535. Walter Kaegi notes that Belisarius's army contained Arian federates who mutinied over religious grievances in 536, doubts the army fought as a Catholic force, and finds Procopius restrained and largely independent of official propaganda ([Kaegi 1965, Traditio](https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/traditio/article/arianism-and-the-byzantine-army-in-africa-533546/A6A4A7B40AF1A26A321E616A177E93D1) [S]).

**#8 Gothic War (535-554), T2 contested.** The casus belli was Queen Amalasuntha's murder; the Arian Goths practised considerable tolerance; Patrick Amory argues the war hardened Italian identities around religion; Italy was devastated and the Lombards invaded in 568 ([Wikipedia, Gothic War](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gothic_War_(535%E2%80%93554)) [W]). **[W-only]**; no explicit anti-Arian war aim was found.

**#9 Kaleb of Axum against Himyar (c. 520-525), T1.** The Himyarite king Dhu Nuwas, a convert to Judaism, persecuted the Christians of Najran; Kaleb's expedition was framed as their defence, killed Dhu Nuwas and later made Kaleb "Saint Elesbaan"; Stuart Munro-Hay judged the venture an overextension ([Wikipedia, Kaleb of Axum](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaleb_of_Axum) [W]). **[W-only]**; dates conflict, and an Egyptian journal article titles a "second campaign" of 525 ([JMIH article title](https://journals.ekb.eg/article_349948.html) [W]). The trade and great-power reading was not fetched.

**#10 Heraclius and the True Cross (602-628), T4 contested.** Persian forces took Jerusalem in 614, seized the True Cross and killed clergy; Heraclius's campaigns of 622-627 reversed the war, the 628 peace returned the relic, and its restoration to Jerusalem is dated by tradition to 21 March 630 ([Medievalists.net, Theotokis on the True Cross](https://www.medievalists.net/2019/04/true-cross-byzantine-sassanid-wars/) [R]). Frolow saw dynastic legitimation in the ceremony's timing and Zuckerman suggested the relic may have been lost (same source); Kaegi rejects the holy-war label (theology section).

**#11 Covadonga (722) and #16 Clavijo (844), T4.** Christian chronicles describe Pelagius's victory over Umayyad commanders as a great slaughter, Umayyad sources as a skirmish, and it later became the founding story of a "Reconquista" whose name is itself a later ideological label ([Wikipedia, Battle of Covadonga](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Covadonga) [W]). Clavijo, where St James supposedly appeared on a white horse, is first reported around 1243 and borrows from the real battle of Monte Laturce (859), per Sánchez-Albornoz; it anchored the Santiago Matamoros cult ([Wikipedia, Battle of Clavijo](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Clavijo) [W]). Both **[W-only]**.

**#12 Tours/Poitiers (732), T4.** In October 732 Charles Martel's Franks held a square on high ground and killed the Umayyad governor ʿAbd al-Raḥmān; Britannica gives about 10,000 Muslim and under 1,000 Frankish dead without a source and still writes that Gaul was preserved for Christianity, showing the traditional frame persists ([Britannica, Battle of Tours](https://www.britannica.com/event/Battle-of-Tours-732) [R]). Paul Fouracre reads the expedition as a long-distance raid ([1440 Review](https://1440review.com/2023/10/14/the-battle-of-tours) [W], **[W-only]** for the attribution). No fetched evidence shows contemporaries framing it as holy war.

**#13 Charlemagne's Saxon wars (772-804), T1.** This is the clearest pre-crusade case of conversion by law and sword. The *Capitulatio de partibus Saxoniae* imposed death for burning a church, killing a cleric, eating meat in Lent out of contempt for Christianity, cremating the dead by pagan rite, and hiding to avoid baptism, allowed confession and penance to commute the penalty, and made tithes compulsory ([Capitulary for Saxony, Fordham](https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/carol-saxony.asp) [P]). At Verden in 782 the Royal Frankish Annals record 4,500 Saxons executed, and the revised annals say beheaded in one day. Historians divide: Lintzel thinks the number exaggerated, Becher posits fewer executions plus deportations, Janet Nelson calls it exemplary legal vengeance for treason, and Alessandro Barbero sees biblical inspiration; Yitzhak Hen's late dating of the Capitulatio (c. 795) is not widely accepted ([Wikipedia, Massacre of Verden](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacre_of_Verden) [W], summarising [S] works).

**#14 Avar wars (788-803), T1.** The 791 invasion opened with three days of fasting, litanies and masses; the Avar "Ring" fell in 795-796; a synod on the Danube in 796 under Paulinus II set baptismal policy, though Walter Pohl warns the sources reflect Frankish propaganda ([Wikipedia, Avar Wars](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avar_Wars) [W]). **[W-only]**. Alcuin's plea that instruction precede baptism survives here only in an AI-assisted translation ([romanletters.org, Alcuin Letter 7](https://romanletters.org/letters/alcuin_york/7/) [W]).

**#15 Papal wars against the Saracens (c. 846-882), T1 precursor.** Leo IV's letter to the Frankish army and John VIII's 878 indulgence promised heaven, eternal life and absolution to those dying against pagans and unbelievers while Muslim raiders threatened Rome ([Colorado War and Society Sourcebook](https://colorado.pressbooks.pub/warandsocietysourcebook/chapter/pre-crusades-forgiveness-of-sin-for-fighting-wars/) [P]). Leo IV's letter is dated variously 848-853 and its authenticity was not checked against scholarship.

**#17 Nikephoros II (961-969), T4.** Nikephoros took Crete (961), campaigned in Cilicia, recovered Cyprus (965) and took Antioch (969), was nicknamed the "White Death of the Saracens" and brought relics home ([WHE, Nikephoros II Phokas](https://www.worldhistory.org/Nikephoros_II_Phokas/) [R]). His demand that fallen soldiers be honoured as martyrs was refused by the patriarch ([Morris 1988](https://cambridge.org/core/journals/byzantine-and-modern-greek-studies/article/two-faces-of-nikephoros-phokas/606BB35357FFB37017D1E97ADDB9F122) [S]).

**#18 Ottonian conquest and the Slav revolt of 983, T1 / AC.** The Lutician federation rose against Ottonian lordship and Christianisation, plundering Havelberg on 29 June 983 and Brandenburg days later; German eastward expansion stalled for some 150-200 years and the Lutici stayed pagan into the 12th century ([Wikipedia, Slavic revolt of 983](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavic_revolt_of_983) [W]). **[W-only]**. The Christian side fused bishoprics with conquest; the war itself was a pagan rising.

**#19 Vladimir and the baptism of Rus' (987-989), T1.** Vladimir helped Basil II crush a rebellion in exchange for marriage to the emperor's sister, took Chersonesos when Basil balked, then had Kiev's idols destroyed and its people baptised in the Dnieper; Novgorod converted only in 989 after violent clashes, and the later Ioakim Chronicle says Christianity came there by fire and sword ([Wikipedia, Christianization of Kievan Rus'](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianization_of_Kievan_Rus%27) [W]). **[W-only]**; Litavrin calls the conversion a formal diplomatic act.

**#20 Hungary and Poland (997-1046), T3 / AC.** Stephen I's defeat of Koppány (997-998), aided by German knights, was a succession war fused with a pagan-Christian divide ([Wikipedia, Koppány](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kopp%C3%A1ny) [W]); in 1046 the Vata rising sought a return to pagan custom and killed bishops, including Gerard, thrown into the Danube ([Wikipedia, Vata pagan uprising](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vata_pagan_uprising) [W]); Poland's pagan reaction of the 1030s destroyed churches and killed priests, read by Prazmowska as both political and pagan revolution ([Wikipedia, Pagan reaction in Poland](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pagan_reaction_in_Poland) [W]). All **[W-only]**.

**#21 Norway (995-1030), T1 / BS.** Olaf Tryggvason reportedly evangelised with torture and beheadings; Olaf II fined or executed those keeping pagan festivals and destroyed a Thor idol. At Stiklestad (1030) Snorri gives Olaf the battle cry of Christ's men, cross men and king's men, yet Knut's army was also Christian and blessed by Bishop Sigurd; the troop numbers are saga conventions ([Christian History Institute, Dead Man Converting](https://christianhistoryinstitute.org/magazine/article/dead-man-converting) [R], confessional). Snorri wrote some 200 years later.

**#22 Barbastro (1063-1064), T1 contested.** Alexander II's letters of late 1063 lifted the penance of those going to fight in Spain and told Spanish bishops that war on persecutors of Christians was just while Jews must not be attacked ([Ott, Letters of Alexander II](https://web.pdx.edu/~ott/hst399/Alexanderletters) [P]). After a 40-day siege in August 1064 the surrender terms were broken and departing defenders killed; the town was retaken on 17 April 1065. Chaytor's 50,000 killed or captured is called greatly exaggerated by Ubieto Arteta, since the town hardly held 8,000 people ([Wikipedia, Crusade of Barbastro](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusade_of_Barbastro) [W]). Menéndez Pidal called it a crusade before the crusades, Ferreiro doubts the papal link (same source), and O'Callaghan argues the papacy transformed the Reconquest into a crusade ([Echevarría, review of O'Callaghan](https://reviews.history.ac.uk/review/344) [S]).

## Eastern crusades, 1095-1699: penitential war from Jerusalem to Vienna

Every entry in this section is Tier 1: papally called or recognised, with remission of sins as the core offer. From 1145 the bulls added legal and financial privileges, and from the 14th century crusading shaded into raids and then into papally financed state alliances. The scholarly consensus since about 1980 accepts sincere penitential devotion as the main driver for most participants, while recognising that leaders, Italian cities and the papacy pursued land, trade and authority.

**#23 People's Crusade and the Rhineland pogroms (1096), T1.** Count Emicho's followers attacked the Jews of Speyer, Worms, Mainz and Cologne, offering conversion or death ([Britannica, Crusades](https://www.britannica.com/event/Crusades) [R]). Solomon bar Samson, writing about 1140, reports the crusaders saying "Now let us avenge the blood of 'the hanged one'", and records some 1,100 killed at Mainz on 27 May 1096, with Jews choosing martyrdom over baptism ([Solomon bar Samson, Fordham](https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/1096jews-mainz.asp) [P]). This is the strongest primary evidence of anti-Jewish violence as a by-product of crusade ideology; the figure is a chronicler's.

**#24 First Crusade (1095-1099), T1.** The crusaders took Antioch on 3 June 1098 and Jerusalem on 15 July 1099 ([Britannica, Crusades](https://www.britannica.com/event/Crusades) [R]). Latin eyewitnesses describe blood to the ankles in the Temple area; Raymond d'Aguilers calls the killing "a just and splendid judgment of God" on a place polluted by blasphemy, and Fulcher, who was not present, gives nearly 10,000 dead in the Temple ([Fordham, Fall of Jerusalem](https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/cde-jlem.asp) [P]). Ibn al-Athīr, writing a century later, gives more than 70,000 in al-Aqsa, and Ibn al-Qalānisī says Jews were burned in their synagogue ([UWM, Muslim accounts trans. Gabrieli](https://sites.uwm.edu/carlin/?p=1017) [P]). Konrad Hirschler shows the Arabic numbers growing over time: early Syrian sources give none, Ibn al-ʿArabī alone gives 3,000, Ibn al-Jawzī first gives 70,000, and later writers reach 100,000; he judges the 70,000 "rather implausible for a minor town such as Jerusalem" ([Hirschler, SOAS repository](https://soas-repository.worktribe.com/OutputFile/347926) [S]). Benjamin Kedar concluded the massacre was considerably more extensive than in other captured towns ([Kedar 2004, Hebrew University record](https://cris.huji.ac.il/en/publications/the-jerusalem-massacre-of-july-1099-in-the-western-historiography/) [S]), and Thomas Fudge finds the sources agree on mass killing that later became "mythistory" ([Fudge 2023, Cambridge World History of Genocide](https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-world-history-of-genocide/crusaders-and-mass-killing-at-jerusalem-in-1099/BD1CDB140A06062FEFC48756DAD78F4E) [S]). Defensible range: **about 3,000 to 10,000**. On motive, Jonathan Riley-Smith's charter studies show crusading was ruinously costly and undercut Duby's "younger sons" thesis ([Holt on Riley-Smith](https://apholt.com/2016/06/08/jonathan-riley-smith-on-the-motivations-of-the-first-crusaders/) [W], summarising [S] works); Christopher Tyerman reads crusade historiography as tied to each era's preoccupations ([IHR review of Tyerman](https://reviews.history.ac.uk/print/review/1153) [S]).

**#25-28 The crusade of 1101, Bohemond, Norway and Venice (1101-1124), T1.** The 1101 reinforcement crusade collapsed in Asia Minor, and Bohemond's papally backed crusade of 1107-1108 attacked Byzantine Dyrrhachium and failed, an early turn of crusading against Eastern Christians ([Britannica, Crusades](https://www.britannica.com/event/Crusades) [R]). Sigurd I sailed with 60 ships in 1107, fought Muslim pirates off the Balearics and helped take Sidon in 1110 ([Britannica, Sigurd I](https://www.britannica.com/biography/Sigurd-I-Magnusson) [R]); Tyre fell in 1124 with Venetian aid, the Venetians receiving a quarter of the city as was customary ([Britannica, Crusades](https://www.britannica.com/event/Crusades) [R]).

**#29 Second Crusade (1145-1149), T1.** Eugenius III issued *Quantum praedecessores* on 1 December 1145 ([WHE, Second Crusade](https://www.worldhistory.org/Second_Crusade/) [R]). The bull granted remission of sins, placed crusaders' families and goods under papal protection, froze lawsuits and relieved interest on debts ([Eugenius III, Fordham](https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/eugene3-2cde.asp) [P]), turning crusading into a legal and financial package as well as a spiritual one. Bernard preached it in France and Germany; it ran on three fronts (the East, Iberia, the Wends); Lisbon fell on 24 October 1147, Seljuks routed Conrad III near Dorylaeum the next day, and the four-day siege of Damascus collapsed on 28 July 1148, which Bernard blamed on the crusaders' sins ([Britannica, Era of the Second and Third Crusades](https://www.britannica.com/event/Crusades/The-era-of-the-Second-and-Third-Crusades) [R]). WHE's army of 60,000 is a low-reliability popular figure. The Templars, founded about 1119-1120 to protect pilgrims and sanctioned at Troyes in 1128, were suppressed in 1312 after Philip IV's arrests ([Britannica, Templars](https://www.britannica.com/topic/Templars) [R]).

**#30 Third Crusade (1189-1192), T1.** After the disaster of 1187 Gregory VIII issued a crusade bull and called for fasting and penance (the title was not confirmed); Barbarossa drowned on 10 June 1190; Acre surrendered in July 1191; when Saladin missed a ransom instalment, Richard had **about 2,700 Muslim prisoners executed**, and Saladin killed most of his Christian captives; the truce of 2 September 1192 left Jerusalem in Muslim hands with pilgrim access ([Britannica, Third Crusade](https://www.britannica.com/event/Crusades/The-Third-Crusade) [R]). The *Itinerarium* records the surrender terms, including release of 2,500 Christian captives ([Itinerarium on Acre, Fordham](https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/source/1191acre.asp) [P]); a revisionist undergraduate paper calls the killing a strategic last resort ([Medievalists.net on Stroik 2010](https://www.medievalists.net/2011/07/22/the-massacre-at-acre-mark-of-a-blood-thirsty-king/) [W]). After Hattin Saladin had captured Templars executed ([Britannica, Templars](https://www.britannica.com/topic/Templars) [R]).

**#31 Fourth Crusade (1202-1204), T1 / BS.** The crusaders' inability to pay the 85,000 marks owed to Venice drove the diversion to Christian Zara and then Constantinople ([Britannica, Fourth Crusade](https://www.britannica.com/event/Fourth-Crusade) [R]). Niketas Choniates describes relics thrown into filth, the altar of Hagia Sophia broken up among soldiers, a prostitute singing on the patriarch's throne and the violation of nuns and matrons ([Choniates, Fordham](https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/choniates1.asp) [P]). No casualty figure was found; the accident-versus-conspiracy debate and later papal apologies were not verified.

**#32 Children's Crusade (1212), T1 popular.** Gary Dickson describes a May-September 1212 movement of young people who took crusade vows without official sanction; none reached the Holy Land, and more than 50 chronicles mention it ([Britannica, Children's Crusade](https://www.britannica.com/event/Childrens-Crusade) [R]).

**#33-36 Fifth to Seventh Crusades (1217-1254), T1.** The Fifth Crusade, planned at the Fourth Lateran Council, took Damietta on 5 November 1219, rejected an offer of Jerusalem under the legate Pelagius, and surrendered in 1221; Francis met al-Kamil during it ([Britannica, Fifth Crusade](https://www.britannica.com/event/Crusades/The-Fifth-Crusade) [R], an AI-summary page). Frederick II, excommunicated in September 1227, regained Jerusalem by the Treaty of Jaffa (18 February 1229) without battle and held it until 1244 ([WHE, Sixth Crusade](https://www.worldhistory.org/Sixth_Crusade/) [R]). The Barons' Crusade won territory by truce in 1239-1241, almost all lost after La Forbie in October 1244 ([Jackson 1987, BSOAS](https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/bulletin-of-the-school-of-oriental-and-african-studies/article/abs/crusades-of-123941-and-their-aftermath/7E0C25AFEC5EAA70E51CF478E72D0998) [S]). Louis IX sailed in 1248 with about 18,000 men, took Damietta, lost his army at Mansurah in 1250, was captured and ransomed for 400,000 livres tournois; the venture cost about 1.5 million ([WHE, Seventh Crusade](https://www.worldhistory.org/Seventh_Crusade/) [R]).

**#37 Shepherds' Crusades (1251, 1320), T1 popular.** In 1251 peasants roused by Louis IX's captivity turned on clergy and towns until Blanche of Castile dispersed them; in 1320 a movement of about 40,000 committed pogroms against Jews and lepers in the Garonne valley ([Britannica, Pastoureaux](https://www.britannica.com/topic/Pastoureaux) [R]). The 1906 Jewish Encyclopedia records Toulouse's Jews massacred except those accepting baptism, besieged Jews at Verdun-sur-Garonne killing one another, **110 Jewish communities destroyed**, condemnation by John XXII and about 2,000 Pastoureaux killed in Aragon ([Jewish Encyclopedia, Pastoureaux](https://jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/11936-pastoureaux) [R]). No total Jewish death toll exists.

**#38-39 Eighth Crusade, Lord Edward and the fall of Acre (1270-1291), T1.** Louis IX died at Tunis on 25 August 1270; the withdrawal treaty freed Christian prisoners, and a storm off Sicily killed about 1,000 men; Edward reached Acre in 1271 with about 1,000 ([WHE, Eighth Crusade](https://www.worldhistory.org/Eighth_Crusade/) [R]). Al-Ashraf Khalil besieged Acre from 6 April to 18 May 1291, after Italian crusaders had attacked Muslim merchants; massacre and enslavement followed and the coastal towns fell by August ([WHE, Siege of Acre 1291](https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1267/the-siege-of-acre-1291-ce/) [R]).

**#40-43 Fourteenth-century crusades (1343-1390), T1.** Clement VI's naval leagues took Smyrna's harbour and fortress in 1344, under the bull *Insurgentibus contra fidem* ([Carr 2011, Royal Holloway thesis](https://rhul.elsevierpure.com/files/2816039/Final_Draft_1.5.pdf) [S]). Peter I of Cyprus seized Alexandria in 1365 in what Britannica calls "a horrible sack and massacre", then withdrew with booty ([Britannica, Peter I of Cyprus](https://www.britannica.com/biography/Peter-I-king-of-Cyprus) [R]). Amadeus VI answered Urban V's call against the Turks in 1366, fighting at Gallipoli and also against Christian Bulgarians ([Britannica, Amadeus VI](https://www.britannica.com/biography/Amadeus-VI) [R]). The 1390 Franco-Genoese siege of Mahdia ended in a tribute deal ([WarHistory.org, Mahdia Crusade](https://warhistory.org/article/mahdia-crusade-1390?amp=0) [W], **[W-only]**).

**#44-45 Nicopolis (1396) and Varna (1444), T1.** Sigismund's Western coalition was crushed by Bayezid I at Nicopolis on 25 September 1396 and most captives were executed ([Britannica, Battle of Nicopolis](https://www.britannica.com/event/Battle-of-Nicopolis) [R]). In 1444 Władysław III broke a ten-year truce under the influence of the papal legate Cesarini and was killed at Varna on 10 November by an army about three times larger ([Britannica, Battle of Varna](https://www.britannica.com/event/Battle-of-Varna) [R]). Neither source gives casualty figures.

**#46-47 Belgrade (1456) and Pius II (1463-1464), T1.** Callixtus III's bull of 29 June 1456 ordered bells rung with prayers against the Ottoman advance; after Hunyadi's victory on 22 July, won with about 27,000 crusaders recruited by John of Capistrano and 12,000 royal troops against more than 60,000 Ottomans, the ringing became linked to the victory ([Visy 2020, Pécs](https://journals.lib.pte.hu/index.php/pontes/article/download/3394/3173/6361) [S]); Capistrano died of plague that October ([Britannica, John of Capistrano](https://www.britannica.com/biography/Saint-John-of-Capistrano) [R]). Pius II proclaimed a crusade on 22 October 1463, took the cross, and died at Ancona waiting for the fleet, which marked the papacy's loss of control of crusading ([New Catholic Encyclopedia, Pius II](https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/pius-ii-pope) [R]).

**#48-49 Lepanto (1571) and the Holy League of 1684, T1.** Pius V brokered the Spanish-Venetian alliance of 25 May 1571; on 7 October Don Juan's fleet captured 117 galleys and freed about 15,000 enslaved Christians; Britannica puts the dead at about 8,000 on each side, with about 8,000 allied wounded (Cervantes among them) ([Britannica, Battle of Lepanto](https://www.britannica.com/event/Battle-of-Lepanto) [R]). Innocent XI subsidised Poland and rallied German princes to relieve Vienna (17 July to 12 September 1683), which Britannica treats as the start of the end of Ottoman dominance in eastern Europe ([Britannica, Siege of Vienna 1683](https://www.britannica.com/event/Siege-of-Vienna-1683) [R]); the Holy League of 5 March 1684 and its end at Karlowitz (26 January 1699) are **[W-only]** ([Wikipedia, Holy League 1684](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holy_League_(1684)) [W]). These leagues show crusading transformed into papally financed state alliances.


## Crusades inside Europe: the indulgence turned on pagans, heretics and rivals

From 1147 the crusade apparatus of vow, indulgence and privileges was extended to the pagan Baltic, to Iberia, to heretics and finally to the papacy's Christian political enemies. Two patterns stand out. Papal authorisation was often reactive, granted to local lords and bishops who already wanted war; and once an opponent was declared heretical or contumacious, Christians could be targeted with the full machinery. Malcolm Barber notes that defining heresy as treason removed the restraints that normally governed war between Christians ([Barber, Wars Like Any Other?, De Re Militari](https://deremilitari.org/?p=1090) [S]).

### The Baltic: missionary war and colonisation

**#50 Wendish Crusade (1147), T1.** Saxon nobles asked to fight the Slavs instead of going east, and Eugenius III's *Divina dispensatione* (11 April 1147) extended the Second Crusade to the Wends and Iberia, although its aim of forcing faith on pagans clashed with canon law against forced conversion ([Latham, What were the Northern Crusades?](https://www.medievalists.net/2019/02/what-were-the-northern-crusades/) [R]). Bernard of Clairvaux forbade any truce for money or tribute until the pagans were "converted or wiped out" ([Bernard, letter on the Wendish crusade, trans. James](https://www.jassa.org/?p=12346) [P], hosted on a non-academic site). The armies besieged Dobin, where the garrison accepted token baptism, and one contingent attacked Stettin, which was already Christian; Helmold of Bosau blamed failure on plunder ([Wikipedia, Wendish Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wendish_Crusade) [W]). Henry the Lion and Valdemar I finished the conquest by about 1185 (Latham [R]).

**#51 Livonian Crusade (c. 1193-1290), T1.** Bishop Albert of Riga, more than Rome, drove the war; he founded the Sword Brothers in 1202, and crusaders received the Holy Land indulgence for a year's service ([Wikipedia, Livonian Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Livonian_Crusade) [W]). The Sword Brothers became a branch of the Teutonic Order in 1237 ([Britannica, Teutonic Order](https://www.britannica.com/topic/Teutonic-Order) [R]). Atrocities ran both ways, all defenders were killed at Tartu in 1224, and conversion stayed nominal (Wikipedia [W]); the Rhymed Chronicle's 100,000 Semigallian emigrants is a chronicle claim.

**#52 Prussian Crusade (1217-1283), T1.** Papal preaching from 1217, Frederick II's Golden Bull of Rimini (1226) and Gregory IX's Golden Bull of Rieti (1234) framed the Teutonic Order's conquest, which began in 1233; Britannica says the Order largely exterminated the native Prussians over 50 years, with a great rebellion in 1261-1283 ([Britannica, Teutonic Order](https://www.britannica.com/topic/Teutonic-Order) [R]). Wikipedia presents a debate between extermination and gradual assimilation through flight, enslavement, conversion and settlement, and shows Peter of Dusburg's troop figures exceeding estimates of the whole Prussian population of about 170,000 ([Wikipedia, Prussian Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prussian_Crusade) [W]).

**#53 Lithuanian Crusade and Grunwald (1283-1422), T1 / BS after 1387.** The Order mounted some 300 campaigns against Lithuania in 1305-1409, kept attacking after Jogaila's baptism (1386) on the claim the conversion was insincere, and was forbidden to do so by a papal bull in 1403 ([Wikipedia, Lithuanian Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithuanian_Crusade) [W]). At Grunwald (15 July 1410) force estimates range wildly by national school, 203-211 of about 270 Teutonic brothers died, Hungarian envoys reported 8,000 dead and a 1412 papal bull mentions 18,000 dead Christians ([Wikipedia, Battle of Grunwald](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Grunwald) [W]). The Order's defeat led on to Toruń (1411, 1466) ([Britannica, Teutonic Order](https://www.britannica.com/topic/Teutonic-Order) [R]). At Constance Paulus Vladimiri attacked these wars as conquest of peoples entitled to their lands (theology section).

**#54 Swedish crusades to Finland (1150s?-1295), T1 contested.** The "First Swedish Crusade" rests on late legends with no archaeological trace ([Wikipedia, First Swedish Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Swedish_Crusade) [W]); the second, against the Tavastians, is dated 1238-1239 or 1249-1250 and known mainly from the propagandist *Erikskrönikan* ([Wikipedia, Second Swedish Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Swedish_Crusade) [W]); the third (1293-1295) founded Viborg and opened 30 years of war with Novgorod, and Wikipedia calls the crusade label largely anachronistic ([Wikipedia, Third Swedish Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Swedish_Crusade) [W]). All **[W-only]**.

**#55 Crusades against Novgorod (1240-1242), T1 contested / BS.** At Lake Peipus (5 April 1242) Alexander Nevsky beat the Livonian Order; the Rhymed Chronicle admits 20 brothers killed, the Novgorod Chronicle claims 400 Germans. Anti Selart notes the papal bulls of 1240-1243 refer to pagans, not Russians; Ostrowski traces the drowning-on-the-ice image to Eisenstein's 1938 film ([Wikipedia, Battle on the Ice](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_on_the_Ice) [W]). **[W-only]**.

### Iberia: the Reconquest as crusade

**#56 Las Navas de Tolosa and the military orders (1158-1212), T1.** In January 1158 Sancho III granted Calatrava to a Cistercian abbot to defend it against "the enemies of the cross of Christ"; the resulting order received papal confirmation about 1164 ([O'Callaghan, New Catholic Encyclopedia, Calatrava](https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/calatrava-order) [R]); the Order of Santiago followed in 1170, papally recognised in 1175 ([Wikipedia, Order of Santiago](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Order_of_Santiago) [W]). Innocent III called the crusade that met the Almohads at Las Navas (16 July 1212); modern estimates put Christian losses near 2,000 and Almohad losses near 20,000, while Alfonso VIII's letter to the pope claims 60,000 Muslims killed at Baeza and a Castilian chronicle almost 100,000 captured; foreign crusaders objected to Alfonso's mercy towards Jews and Muslims ([Wikipedia, Las Navas de Tolosa](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Las_Navas_de_Tolosa) [W], **[W-only]** for figures).

**#57 Granada War (1482-1492), T1.** Papal crusade grants funded the Catholic Monarchs from 1478 ([Wikipedia, Crusade bull](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusade_bull) [W]); a surviving 1490 printed indulgence shows Innocent VIII renewing the crusade, with a third of proceeds going to the war ([Bridwell Library, Spanish indulgence](https://bridwell.omeka.net/exhibits/show/luther/antecedents/spanishindulgence) [R]). Málaga's inhabitants were mostly enslaved in 1487; the 1491 treaty promised no forced conversions, a guarantee broken by Cisneros's mass conversions, and by 1501 Granada's Muslims faced conversion, slavery or exile ([Wikipedia, Granada War](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Granada_War) [W]). The 100,000 dead or enslaved is an unsourced aggregate; Weston Cook stresses gunpowder and state-building (same source).

### Crusades against heretics and dissenters

**#58 Albigensian Crusade (1209-1244), T1 / BS.** Innocent III called it in March 1208 after a legate's murder; Béziers was sacked and its population nearly wiped out in July 1209, Simon de Montfort held most of the region by 1215, and the 1229 treaty passed Toulouse to the Capetians, leaving the French crown "the ultimate winner" ([Britannica, Albigensian Crusade](https://www.britannica.com/event/Albigensian-Crusade) [R]). The legate Arnaud Amalric reported nearly 20,000 killed at Béziers; the words "Kill them all, God will know his own" survive only in Caesarius of Heisterbach, writing in Germany in 1219-1223 and saying merely that Amalric was reported to have said them ([Wikipedia, Caedite eos](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caedite_eos._Novit_enim_Dominus_qui_sunt_eius.) [W]). Barber records blinding and mutilation at Bram (1210), executions at Lavaur (1211) and massacre at Marmande (1219), and concludes the war "went far beyond the normal conventions" of its time ([Barber, De Re Militari](https://deremilitari.org/?p=1090) [S]). Mark Pegg goes further, describing "a moral imperative to genocide" in the holy war from its start ([Pegg, OUPblog](https://blog.oup.com/2008/03/religious_violence/) [S]). About 210 Cathars were burned after Montségur fell in March 1244 ([Wikipedia, Siege of Montségur](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Monts%C3%A9gur) [W]).

**#59-61 Drenthe, Stedinger and Bosnia (1228-1241), T1 / BS.** The Drenther crusade's bull does not survive and the bishop of Utrecht may have acted alone, with heresy meaning defiance of his lordship ([Wikipedia, Drenther Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drenther_Crusade) [W], **[W-only]**). The Stedinger peasants of the lower Weser, in a tithe dispute with the archbishop of Bremen, were branded heretics on an unsubstantiated charge and attacked by the archbishop's brother and local nobles until Gregory IX granted full crusade privileges in 1234 ([Britannica, Stedinger Crusade](https://www.britannica.com/print/article/1386466) [R]). Crusade preaching was authorised by *Lucis eterne lumine* (29 October 1232); the crusaders' victory at Altenesch on 27 May 1234 was followed by massacre, with chronicle tolls of 2,000 to 11,000 that cannot be taken literally ([Wikipedia, Stedinger Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stedinger_Crusade) [W]). The Bosnian crusade of 1235-1241 gave Hungary a pretext to reassert suzerainty, and the Bosnian Church's dualism is attested in a single source ([Wikipedia, Bosnian Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bosnian_Crusade) [W], **[W-only]**).

**#62-66 Political crusades against Christian rulers (1239-1383), T1 / BS.** Gregory IX excommunicated Frederick II in 1227 and again in 1239, and a 1246 account records some taking the cross against him ([Catholic Encyclopedia 1909, Frederick II](https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06255a.htm) [R]). Martin IV declared a crusade against Peter III of Aragon after the Sicilian Vespers; the 1285 French invasion collapsed amid naval defeat and dysentery, and Chaytor judged it among the most unjust Capetian ventures ([Wikipedia, Aragonese Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aragonese_Crusade) [W]). Boniface VIII proclaimed a crusade against the Colonna cardinals in 1297, ending with the fall of Palestrina ([Schaff, History of the Christian Church VI](https://ccel.org/ccel/schaff/hcc6.ii.ii.ii.html) [R]; [Wikipedia, Crusade against the Colonna](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusade_against_the_Colonna_family) [W]). Crusaders took Fra Dolcino's mountain stronghold on 23 March 1307 and he was burned that year ([Wikipedia, Fra Dolcino](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fra_Dolcino) [W], **[W-only]**). Urban VI's bulls of 1381 sent Bishop Despenser on a Schism crusade in 1383 that besieged Ypres, a city of Urban's own obedience, while also serving English wool interests; Parliament impeached him ([Wikipedia, Despenser's Crusade](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Despenser%27s_Crusade) [W], **[W-only]**). These are the clearest cases where the crusade label covered Christian-against-Christian power politics.

**#67 Hussite Wars (1419-1434), T1 versus T2 / BS.** After Jan Hus was burned at Constance in 1415, the Hussites fought under the Four Articles of Prague: free preaching, communion in both kinds, stripping clergy of wealth and punishing public sin ([Britannica, Hussite Wars](https://www.britannica.com/event/Hussite-Wars) [R]; [Wikipedia, Hussite Wars](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hussite_Wars) [W]). Martin V's bull *Omnium plasmatoris domini*, dated 1 March and proclaimed 17 March 1420 ([AskHistorians, citing Fudge](https://red.ks32.dev/r/AskHistorians/comments/1g5c4qf/is_the_papal_bull_omnium_plasmatoris_domini) [W]), called for the destruction "of the Wycliffites, Hussites and all other heretics in Bohemia" (Wikipedia [W]). Five crusades (1420, 1421, 1422, 1427, 1431) failed, the last routed at Domažlice despite a four-to-one advantage ([Medievalists.net, summarising Fudge 2004](https://www.medievalists.net/?p=23397) [R]); radical Taborites were destroyed by a Utraquist-Catholic coalition at Lipany in 1434 (Wikipedia [W]). Atrocities ran both ways: Catholic miners at Kutná Hora threw Hussites into mine shafts ([History of the Germans blog](https://historyofthegermans.com/2025/01/zizka/) [W]) and Žižka massacred Prachatice and burned priests in a lime kiln ([Lovecpokladu.cz](https://www.lovecpokladu.cz/en/home/12-11-1420-zizka-conquered-prachatice-8286) [W]), both **[W-only]**. Bohemia's population fell from about 2.8-3.4 million around 1400 to 1.5-1.85 million by 1526, a span far longer than the wars (Wikipedia [W]).

## Reformation-era wars, 1524-1712: doctrine fused with state power

These are Tier 2 confessional wars almost by definition, yet confessional lines were crossed constantly: Lutheran and Catholic forces besieged Anabaptist Münster together, a Protestant prince won the Schmalkaldic War for the Catholic emperor, Philip II covertly aided Huguenots, Catholic France fought Catholic Spain, and Protestant Dutch guns helped crush Japanese Catholics. The historiography is a spectrum. Peter H. Wilson calls the Thirty Years' War a struggle over the Empire's political and religious order that was "neither inevitable nor a religious conflict" ([Wilson, Rorotoko interview](https://www.rorotoko.com/micro-interviews/20100423-wilson-peter-on-europe-tragedy-history-thirty-years-war-1) [S]); Britannica judges that "reason of state was a stronger determinant of policy than faith" ([Britannica, Germany: Thirty Years' War](https://www.britannica.com/place/Germany/The-Thirty-Years-War-and-the-Peace-of-Westphalia) [R]); William Cavanaugh argues the *wars of religion* story is a founding myth of the secular state, which in his account "became itself sacralized" ([Appleby, review of Cavanaugh, Commonweal](https://commonwealmagazine.org/fire-sword) [R]; [The Other Journal, review of Cavanaugh](https://theotherjournal.com/2011/02/religion-and-its-discontents-a-review-of-the-myth-of-religious-violence/) [R]); and Mack Holt, following Natalie Zemon Davis, holds that the French wars were genuinely religious if religion means "a body of believers" whose purity had to be defended ([Leithart on Holt, First Things](https://firstthings.com/wars-of-decontamination/) [R]). The strongest counter-evidence to Cavanaugh is that some disputes turned on religion alone, such as the Camisards' demand for toleration.

**#68 German Peasants' War (1524-1525), T2.** Old economic grievances over rents, tributes and forced labour were recast as demands under God's law, meaning the Gospel; the Swabian Twelve Articles, drafted by an Evangelical cleric, declared "The Bible proves that we are free" and claimed each congregation's right to choose its pastor; Luther urged the princes to cut the rebels down and later made the separation of the two realms binding ([Britannica, Revolution of 1525](https://www.Britannica.Com/place/Germany/The-revolution-of-1525) [R]). About 100,000 peasants died; Lyndal Roper estimates up to 6,000 at Frankenhausen, and Müntzer was executed on 27 May 1525 ([WHE, German Peasants' War](https://www.worldhistory.org/German_Peasants'_War/) [R]).

**#69-71 Kappel, Münster and the Count's Feud (1529-1536), T2.** Zwingli was killed near Kappel on 11 October 1531 ([Britannica, Zwingli](https://www.britannica.com/biography/Huldrych-Zwingli) [R]), and the 1531 peace established Catholic predominance in the Confederacy ([Canton of Aargau, Villmergen 1712](https://www.ag.ch/de/themen/kultur-sport/kultur/kulturkanton/erinnerungskultur/villmergerkrieg-landfrieden-aarau-1712/geschichte-1712) [R]). Anabaptists under Jan Mathijs and John of Leiden seized Münster and were besieged by the bishop and nobles; John was executed in 1536 and the cages that held the bodies still hang from St Lambert's ([Britannica, John of Leiden](https://www.britannica.com/biography/John-of-Leiden) [R]). Denmark's Count's Feud (1534-1536) and the Cologne War (#79, 1583-1588, triggered by the prince-archbishop's turn to Calvinism) appear here only on **[W-only]** listing ([Wikipedia, European wars of religion](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_wars_of_religion) [W]).

**#72 Pilgrimage of Grace (1536), T2.** Resentment of Thomas Cromwell's centralisation, enclosure and the dissolution of the smaller monasteries brought some 30,000 armed men under Robert Aske; Norfolk dispersed them with a pardon, then about 220-250 were executed ([Britannica, Pilgrimage of Grace](https://www.britannica.com/event/Pilgrimage-of-Grace) [R]).

**#73 Schmalkaldic War (1546-1547), T2.** The issue was imperial authority versus the survival of German Protestantism; the pope offered Charles V 1.1 million ducats and troops, but the Protestant Maurice of Saxony changed sides for land and an electoral vote, and Charles won at Mühlberg on 24 April 1547 ([EBSCO, Schmalkaldic War](https://ebsco.com/research-starters/history/schmalkaldic-war) [R]). The Princes' Revolt of 1552 led to the Peace of Augsburg (1555), which let princes choose Lutheranism or Catholicism for their lands and excluded Calvinists ([Britannica, Peace of Augsburg](https://www.britannica.com/event/Peace-of-Augsburg) [R]).

**#74 Prayer Book Rebellion (1549), T2.** Devon and Cornwall parishioners forced their priest to say the Latin service against the new English Prayer Book, and rebels demanded the old services, some arguing that Cornish speakers understood no English ([Devon Perspectives, Part 1](https://devonperspectives.co.uk/prayerbook_rebellion_1.html) [W]); they besieged Exeter under the Banner of the Five Wounds ([Devon Perspectives, Part 2](https://devonperspectives.co.uk/prayerbook_rebellion_2.html) [W]) and were routed at Sampford Courtenay on 17 August 1549, with death tolls disputed ([Devon Perspectives, Part 5](https://devonperspectives.co.uk/prayerbook_rebellion_5.html) [W]). **[W-only]**; the widely quoted 4,000-5,500 total is unverified.

**#75 French Wars of Religion (1562-1598), T2.** The Guise massacre of a Huguenot congregation at Vassy (1562) began the wars; Philip II backed the Catholics yet sometimes covertly aided Huguenots; Henry IV's conversion and the Edict of Nantes (1598) ended them ([Britannica, Wars of Religion](https://www.britannica.com/event/Wars-of-Religion) [R]). The St Bartholomew's Day Massacre (24 August 1572 onward) was planned by Catherine de' Medici, approved by Charles IX, celebrated by a medal struck for Gregory XIII, and drove Huguenots towards theories of justified rebellion; estimates run from 2,000 (a Catholic apologist) to 70,000 (Sully), with about 3,000 in Paris ([Britannica, St Bartholomew's Day](https://www.britannica.com/event/Massacre-of-Saint-Bartholomews-Day) [R]). Holt gives about 2,000 in Paris plus about 3,000 in the provinces ([Holt excerpt, unofficial host](https://www.harvestherald.com/sop/fwor.html) [S]). Overall: about 4 million including famine and disease ([WHE, French Wars of Religion](https://www.worldhistory.org/French_Wars_of_Religion/.md) [R]); the 2-4 million range is common but its scholarly origin was not verified ([Wikipedia, European wars of religion](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_wars_of_religion) [W]).

**#76 Eighty Years' War (1568-1648), T2 partly.** The Calvinist Sea Beggars took Holland and Zeeland by 1573, the Catholic Walloon provinces defected in 1579, and Spain recognised Dutch independence in 1648; Britannica explains the outcome mainly through military events and great-power rivalry ([Britannica, Eighty Years' War](https://www.britannica.com/event/Eighty-Years-War) [R]). Religion entered through the 1566 iconoclasm and Alba's Council of Troubles; deaths are put at 100,000-500,000 ([WHE, Eighty Years' War](https://www.worldhistory.org/Eighty_Years'_War/.md) [R]), against 600,000-700,000 on Wikipedia [W].

**#77-78 Desmond Rebellions and the Armada (1569-1604), T2.** James Fitzmaurice FitzGerald returned in 1579 with papal troops, the Jesuit Nicholas Sanders at his side, in a rising described as "the first overt sign of the Counter-Reformation in Ireland"; about 600 papal soldiers were massacred after surrendering at Smerwick (1580), and confiscations created the Munster Plantation ([Encyclopedia of Irish History and Culture, Desmond Rebellions](https://www.encyclopedia.com/international/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/desmond-rebellions) [R]). Pius V's *Regnans in Excelsis* (25 February 1570) declared Elizabeth a heretic and her subjects "forever absolved from such an oath" of allegiance ([Regnans in Excelsis, Papal Encyclicals](https://www.papalencyclicals.net/pius05/p5regnans.htm) [P]); Aislinn Muller shows English subjects took it seriously ([Muller 2017, Studies in Church History](https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/studies-in-church-history/article/transmitting-and-translating-the-excommunication-of-elizabeth-i/9AF60A76430F217253D0C482D45B01AF) [S]). Geoffrey Parker records Sixtus V's promise to pay a third of the cost of conquering England, and the Armada's loss of a third of its ships and half of its 30,000 men ([Parker, The Past](https://the-past.com/feature/why-the-armada-failed/) [R]).

**#80 Thirty Years' War (1618-1648), T2 contested.** On 23 May 1618 Protestant lords threw the regents from a Prague Castle window, accusing them of undermining the 1609 Letter of Majesty, while the crowd called them "enemies of our religion" ([GHDI, Defenestration of Prague](https://germanhistorydocs.org/en/from-the-reformations-to-the-thirty-years-war-1500-1648/the-war-begins-the-defenestration-of-prague-may-1618) [P]). The Edict of Restitution (1629) demanded the return of over 500 church properties and united Catholic and Protestant estates against the emperor; imperial troops massacred two-thirds of Magdeburg's roughly 20,000 people in 1631; Westphalia (1648) admitted Calvinists and fixed 1624 as the normative year ([Britannica, Germany: Thirty Years' War](https://www.britannica.com/place/Germany/The-Thirty-Years-War-and-the-Peace-of-Westphalia) [R]). Britannica calls it a series of wars for various reasons ([Britannica, Thirty Years' War](https://www.britannica.com/event/Thirty-Years-War) [R]). **Deaths: about 1.8 million soldiers and at least 3.2 million civilians**, a fall of at least a fifth of the Empire's population (Wilson [S]); Britannica gives 15-20% including epidemics, with over half dead or vanished in places such as Württemberg [R]; Wikipedia's 4-12 million [W] overshoots both.

**#81 Huguenot rebellions and La Rochelle (1621-1629), T2.** La Rochelle sided with an English invasion, and after Richelieu's sea wall blocked relief it surrendered after 15 months with three-quarters of its citizens starved ([Britannica, La Rochelle](https://www.britannica.com/place/La-Rochelle) [R]). An overall toll of up to 100,000 is **[W-only]**.

**#82 Shimabara Rebellion (1637-1638), T3 / AC.** Peasants of Shimabara and Amakusa, mostly Catholic converts, rose against heavy taxation and official abuse; the revolt "took on Christian overtones", needed a Dutch gunboat to subdue, ended in the slaughter of some 37,000, and drove Japanese Christianity underground ([Britannica, Shimabara Rebellion](https://www.britannica.com/event/Shimabara-Rebellion) [R]). Japan's transport ministry adds that the Matsukura clan was brutally repressing Christianity while raising taxes, and names the 16-year-old Amakusa Shirō as leader of nearly 37,000 defenders at Hara Castle against more than 120,000 troops ([MLIT, Shimabara text](https://www.mlit.go.jp/tagengo-db/common/001563310.pdf) [R]). The display of some 30,000 heads is **[W-only]** ([Tabi-Samurai-Japan](https://en.tabi-samurai-japan.com/story/event/441/2/) [W]).

**#83 Bishops' Wars and the Wars of the Three Kingdoms (1639-1651), T2.** Charles I's imposition of a prayer book on Scotland (1637) produced the National Covenant and the Bishops' Wars; the Irish Catholic rising of October 1641 sought, among other aims, the restoration of the Catholic Church to its pre-Reformation position ([Britannica, English Civil Wars](https://www.Britannica.Com/event/English-Civil-Wars) [R]). The Solemn League and Covenant (1643) pledged "the extirpation of Popery, prelacy" ([Solemn League and Covenant, Gardiner](https://constitution.org/1-History/eng/conpur058.htm) [P]), and the Scots saw it as a religious pact ([EBSCO, Solemn League and Covenant](https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/history/solemn-league-and-covenant) [R]). The Irish Confederates swore an oath of association "for God, King and Country", and the papal nuncio Rinuccini excommunicated supporters of a 1648 truce ([Lenihan, Confederation of Kilkenny](https://www.encyclopedia.com/international/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/confederation-kilkenny) [R]). William Haller credits preaching in the New Model Army with its success ([Haller 1950, Church History](https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/church-history/article/abs/word-of-god-in-the-new-model-army/9E9170DCDA93D9587575B1CD3A6F389D) [S]). Casualties: Charles Carlton estimates over 40% of Ireland's population died of war-related causes, while David Underdown notes Petty's quarter to a third ([Underdown, LRB review of Carlton](https://www.lrb.co.uk/v15/n11/david-underdown/praising-god) [S]); a reader's letter gives 618,000 Irish dead ([Griffin, History Ireland letter](https://www.originalsite.historyireland.com/?p=13086) [W]). The 1641 settler toll shows propaganda inflation: perhaps 4,000 dead against the Irish government's claim of 154,000 (Britannica [R]), and a 2011 study found the 1641 depositions dominated by hearsay ([Irish Times 2011](https://www.irishtimes.com/news/1641-rebellion-massacre-reports-based-on-hearsay-study-shows-1.574938) [R]). John Morrill's description of the English Revolution as the last of the Wars of Religion is reported via Wikipedia [W].

**#84 Cromwell at Drogheda (1649), T2.** Cromwell reported about 2,000 men put to the sword in one night and the friars killed indiscriminately, and explicitly tied the massacre to 1641, calling it "a righteous Judgement of God upon these Barbarous wretches" ([Cromwell to Lenthall, 17 September 1649](https://www.olivercromwell.org/wordpress/cromwell-to-speaker-lenthall-17-september-1649/) [P]).

**#85-89 Late confessional wars (1656-1710), T2.** Catholic victory in the First Villmergen War (1656) confirmed the 1531 order; in 1712 Zürich and Bern backed the Reformed Toggenburgers against the Abbot of St Gallen, won at Villmergen on 25 July and tilted the Confederacy towards the Reformed cantons, at a cost of about 4,000 dead and wounded ([Canton of Aargau](https://www.ag.ch/de/themen/kultur-sport/kultur/kulturkanton/erinnerungskultur/villmergerkrieg-landfrieden-aarau-1712/geschichte-1712) [R]). Solovetsky's monks resisted Nikon's liturgical reforms through an eight-year siege (1668-1676), after which most were killed ([Walters Art Museum, MS W.916](https://art.thewalters.org/detail/1276) [R]); the councils of 1666-1667 had anathematised the dissenters and Avvakum was later executed ([Britannica, Old Believers](https://www.britannica.com/topic/Old-Believers) [R]). Presbyterian Covenanters rose against reimposed episcopacy and lost at Bothwell Bridge (22 June 1679), with about 400 dead in the rout and 1,200 prisoners ([Historic Environment Scotland, BTL5](https://portal.historicenvironment.scot/designation/BTL5) [R]). The Williamite War was a Protestant victory in Ireland, with about 7,000 Jacobites killed at Aughrim, yet Catholic Austria and Spain greeted the Boyne with Te Deums because it weakened Louis XIV ([Finnegan, Jacobites and Williamite Wars](https://www.encyclopedia.com/international/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/jacobites-and-williamite-wars) [R]). After the revocation of the Edict of Nantes, prophet-led Camisards rose in the Cévennes in 1702, and the crown was "willing to grant amnesty but not religious toleration" ([Britannica, Camisard](https://www.britannica.com/topic/Camisard) [R]).


## Colonial conquest, 1344-1900: papal grants, the Requerimiento and the Christian critics

Iberian expansion carried the crusade into law. A chain of papal bulls licensed conquest and enslavement on condition of spreading the faith, Castile turned this into a formal ultimatum read before attacks, and US courts later absorbed it as the Doctrine of Discovery. The religious framing was strongest and most legalised in Spanish America, most providentialist in Puritan New England, and thinnest in Siberia and Portuguese Africa, where tribute and slaves plainly came first. Several conflicts in this section were Christian against Christian or were risings against Christian coercion.

### The legal chain from crusade bull to Doctrine of Discovery

Clement VI granted the Canary Islands to Luis de la Cerda in 1344 and gave their conquest crusade status with indulgences in 1345 ([Wikipedia, Conquest of the Canary Islands](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conquest_of_the_Canary_Islands) [W], **[W-only]**). Nicholas V's *Dum diversas* (18 June 1452) and *Romanus Pontifex* (8 January 1455) empowered Portugal's Afonso V to "invade, search out, capture, vanquish, and subdue" Saracens and pagans, reduce them to perpetual slavery and take their lands ([College of Charleston LDHI, Pope Nicolas V and the Portuguese](https://ldhi.library.cofc.edu/exhibits/show/african_laborers_for_a_new_emp/pope_nicolas_v_and_the_portugu) [R], quoting Davenport's translation); the same wording is attributed to *Dum diversas* ([WHE, Doctrine of Discovery](https://www.worldhistory.org/Doctrine_of_Discovery/.md) [R]). Alexander VI's *Inter caetera* (4 May 1493) gave Castile the lands west of a line 100 leagues beyond the Azores, with the aim that "barbarous nations be overthrown and brought to the faith itself", on condition that missionaries be sent, and threatened rival Europeans, not natives, with excommunication ([Inter caetera, Papal Encyclicals](https://www.papalencyclicals.net/alex06/alex06inter.htm) [P]). The 1513 *Requerimiento*, drafted by Juan López de Palacios Rubios, demanded submission to the Church and crown and warned that war, enslavement and all resulting deaths would be the natives' fault; it was read in Castilian to people who could not understand it, sometimes to empty beaches ([Wikipedia, Spanish Requirement of 1513](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Requirement_of_1513) [W]). Recorded uses include Colombia (1513), Atahualpa (1532) and the Chichimeca (1540s), and Las Casas called it unjust, impious and absurd ([WHE, Spanish Requirement](https://www.worldhistory.org/Spanish_Requirement/.md) [R]); one timeline dates its abolition to 1556 ([Lehigh University, History on Trial timeline](https://history-on-trial.lib.lehigh.edu/trial/justification/newspain/time/) [R]), while Philip II's 1573 ordinance replaced the word *conquest* with *pacification* ([History Today, Valladolid debate](https://www.historytoday.com/archive/months-past/valladolid-debate-rights-indigenous-people) [R]). In *Johnson v. M'Intosh* (1823) the US Supreme Court held that discovery gave exclusive title, leaving Native peoples only a right of occupancy, and commentators link the doctrine to the 15th-century bulls ([Library of Congress Law blog, Doctrine of Discovery](https://blogs.loc.gov/law/2023/07/doctrine-of-discovery-until-otherwise/) [R]).

The Christian counter-case was made at the same time. On the fourth Sunday of Advent 1511 Dominicans in Santo Domingo asked the colonists "Are they not men?" and declared them in mortal sin; the Laws of Burgos (1512) curbed some abuses but legalised the *encomienda* ([Seton Hall, Montesinos sermon](https://www.shu.edu/documents/aretheynotmen.pdf) [R]). Paul III's *Sublimis Deus* (1537) declared that "the Indians are truly men" who must not be enslaved or stripped of property and should be converted by preaching and example ([Sublimis Deus, Papal Encyclicals](https://www.papalencyclicals.net/paul03/p3subli.htm) [P]). At Valladolid (1550-1551), after Charles V halted conquests, Sepúlveda argued from Aristotle that the Indians were natural slaves, and Las Casas replied over five days; no verdict was given and conquest continued ([History Today](https://www.historytoday.com/archive/months-past/valladolid-debate-rights-indigenous-people) [R]). On 30 March 2023 two Vatican dicasteries repudiated the Doctrine of Discovery and said the bulls had "never been considered expressions of the Catholic faith", calling them manipulated by colonial powers ([Vatican News, Joint Note on the Doctrine of Discovery](https://www.vaticannews.va/en/vatican-city/news/2023-03/vatican-formally-repudiates-doctrine-of-discovery.html) [P], official Vatican outlet); the note did not rescind the bulls, and its effect beyond the Church remains to be seen ([LOC Law blog](https://blogs.loc.gov/law/2023/07/doctrine-of-discovery-until-otherwise/) [R]).

### Conquests and wars

**#90 Canary Islands (1402-1496), T1.** Conquest ran from Béthencourt's expeditions (1402-1405) to Tenerife's surrender (1496), alongside slave raiding from the 1340s; Guanches lost about 1,700 men at Aguere (1494), and Mohamed Adhikari calls the conquest Europe's first overseas settler-colonial genocide ([Wikipedia, Conquest of the Canary Islands](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conquest_of_the_Canary_Islands) [W]). **[W-only]**.

**#91 Ceuta and the Portuguese Atlantic (1415-1450s), T1.** Nearly 20,000 men under João I took Ceuta on 22 August 1415 in an effort to revive crusading, followed by massacre and looting ([WHE, Prince Henry the Navigator](https://www.worldhistory.org/Prince_Henry_the_Navigator/.md) [R]). From 1441 Portuguese raids seized Africans for sale, with Zurara recording Prince Henry's joy, and *Romanus Pontifex* gave the trade legal cover; Kongo's Christian ruler later used his religious status to try to limit the slave trade (CofC LDHI [R]).

**#92 Spanish Caribbean (1492-1540s), T1.** Las Casas wrote that 60,000 people remained on Hispaniola when he arrived in 1508; estimates for 1492 range from 100,000 to 8 million, with forced labour, famine, violence and smallpox cited as causes ([Stoneking 2009, student thesis](https://teamsocialstudies.media.uconn.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/47/2021/04/The-Decline-of-the-Tainos-1492-1542_-A-Re-Vision-1.pdf) [W]). **[W-only]** for the range.

**#93 Conquest of the Aztec Empire (1519-1521), T1.** Cortés thanked God for victories, ordered temples cleansed and converted with crosses and images of the Virgin, and was urged by a Mercedarian friar not to force conversion at Tlaxcala and Cholula; one explanation of the Toxcatl massacre is Spanish fear of rebellion over the imposed cross and image ([AHA, Religious Conflicts in the Conquest of Mexico](https://www.historians.org/resource/religious-conflicts-in-the-conquest-of-mexico/) [R]). Bernal Díaz describes Cempoala's priests weeping as their idols were smashed ([Bernal Díaz, ch. XXXV](https://www.latinamericanstudies.org/cempoala.htm) [P], weak host), and a confessional magazine quotes Cortés asking "Shall we not do something for God?" while noting he trapped and slaughtered Cholula's leaders ([Christian History, The Christian Conquerors](https://www.christianhistoryinstitute.org/magazine/article/christian-conquerors) [R]). His banner's cross and Constantinian motto are attested only via a hobbyist summary of the chroniclers ([Flags of the World, Cortés's banner](https://crwflags.com/FOTW/FLAGS/mx_1521.html) [W]). No casualty total was retrieved.

**#94 Conquest of the Inca Empire (1532-1530s), T1.** At Cajamarca on 16 November 1532 Friar Vicente de Valverde urged Atahualpa to abandon his gods; when the Inca threw down the proffered book, Valverde declared the Indians enemies of the faith and the Spaniards fired on the unarmed crowd ([PBS, Conquistadors: Pizarro](https://www.pbs.org/conquistadors/pizarro/pizarro_g00.html) [R]). The 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia notes that the eyewitness Xerez records nothing improper in Valverde's conduct and calls the charge unproven ([Catholic Encyclopedia, Vicente de Valverde](https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/15265a.htm) [R], dated and denominational).

**#95-97 Maya, Mixtón and Chichimeca (c. 1517-1697), T1.** The Maya conquest ran from Champotón (c. 1517) through Alvarado's burning of Utatlán and Iximché and Montejo's campaigns to Bishop Landa's burning of Maya books at Maní (c. 1562), which the Council of the Indies condemned; by about 1580 war, epidemics, slavery and forced labour had devastated the population ([Met Museum, Heilbrunn Timeline](https://www.metmuseum.org/toah/ht/08/cana.html) [R]). In the Mixtón War (1540-1542), Caxcanes driven by Nuño de Guzmán's killings and enslavement killed two priests and were crushed by Viceroy Mendoza with tens of thousands of Indigenous allies ([Wikipedia, Mixtón War](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mixt%C3%B3n_War) [W], **[W-only]**). Whether total war against the Chichimecas was just was, in Stafford Poole's words, a burning question: theologians in 1570 called it lawful and even "a positive obligation", while bishops and Franciscans opposed it and the Third Mexican Council (1585) debated whether the Chichimecas were wards of the crown ([Poole 1965, The Americas](https://core-prod.cambridgecore.org/core/journals/americas/article/war-by-fire-and-blood-the-church-and-the-chichimecas-1585/83FE1CD6C01276970292F1480481F3CA) [S]).

**#98 The Philippines (1565-1898), T1.** Legazpi reached Cebu in 1565 and made Manila the capital in 1571; the Spaniards treated baptism as a sign of allegiance, Philip II ordered a bloodless pacification, and conflict with the Muslim "Moros" was intermittent ([LOC Country Study, Philippines](https://countrystudies.us/philippines/4.htm) [R]). In 1578 Governor de Sande went to war with Brunei after demanding freedom to proselytise and an end to Brunei's spread of Islam ([Wikipedia, Castilian War](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castilian_War) [W], **[W-only]**).

**#99 Ethiopian-Adal War (1529-1543), T3.** Imam Ahmad ibn Ibrahim of Adal used the term jihad, defeated the Ethiopian emperor in 1529 and destroyed churches including St Mary of Zion at Axum; about 400 Portuguese musketeers under Cristóvão da Gama landed in 1541, Gama was executed after refusing to convert, and Ahmad was killed at Wayna Daga in 1543 ([New World Encyclopedia, Ahmad ibn Ibrahim](https://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Ahmad_ibn_Ibrihim_al-Ghazi) [W]). **[W-only]**; the Christian side defended a Christian kingdom, with Portuguese help framed as aid to fellow Christians.

**#100 Russian conquest of Siberia (1581-1778), T4.** Fur tribute (*yasak*) drove the conquest; spreading Orthodoxy was a secondary, largely ad hoc pretext, though forced conversion contributed to a 1740s revolt ([Wikipedia, Russian conquest of Siberia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_conquest_of_Siberia) [W]). **[W-only]**.

**#101 Pequot War and King Philip's War (1636-1676), T1 informal.** At Mystic on 26 May 1637 colonial forces and Native allies burned a fort holding 400-700 Pequots; John Mason credited God and called the fort "a fiery oven", and pastors cast the Pequots as servants of Satan threatening Christ's kingdom. M. J. Tuininga argues the war turned a professed mission to convert into conquest, and in King Philip's War, perhaps the bloodiest per capita in American history, Christian and non-Christian Natives fought on both sides ([Tuininga, OUPblog](https://blog.oup.com/2025/01/the-massacre-at-fort-mystic-and-the-puritan-wars-of-the-lord) [S]). No church authorised these wars, hence "informal".

**#102 Kongo and Portugal at Mbwila (1665), T4 / BS.** Catholic Kongo under António I fought Portuguese Angola over territory, mines and a succession dispute; António and over 5,000 Kongolese soldiers died and the kingdom fragmented; the source names no religious cause ([EBSCO, Battle of Mbwila](https://ebsco.com/research-starters/military-history-and-science/battle-mbwila) [R]).

**#103 Pueblo Revolt (1680), AC.** Popé organised the revolt after missionaries burned kivas and sacred objects and punished medicine men; about 400 Spaniards, including 21 priests, were killed and churches destroyed, and Vargas reconquered the province in 1692 ([Britannica, Pueblo Rebellion](https://www.britannica.com/event/Pueblo-Rebellion) [R]).

**#104 Goa Inquisition (1560-1812), T1 coercion.** Established after Francis Xavier's urging, it targeted converts accused of crypto-Hinduism; about 160 temples were razed on Goa island by 1566, trial counts range from 3,800 to 16,000, and 57 people were burned ([Wikipedia, Goa Inquisition](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goa_Inquisition) [W]). **[W-only]**; a coercion regime, not a war.

**#105-106 Greek War of Independence and Circassia (1763-1878), T3.** William St Clair argued that bishops and priests urged their flocks to exterminate Muslims in 1821; Muslim civilian deaths at Tripolitsa are put at 6,000-15,000, the Ottomans hanged the Patriarch on Easter Sunday 1821, and up to 100,000 were reportedly killed or enslaved at Chios in 1822 ([Wikipedia, Massacres in the Greek War of Independence](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacres_in_the_Greek_War_of_Independence) [W]). The Russo-Circassian War and expulsions are attributed partly to Russia's messianic self-image as champion of Orthodoxy, with death estimates from about 400,000 to 1.5 million, and Russia rejects the genocide label ([Wikipedia, Circassian genocide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circassian_genocide) [W]). Both **[W-only]**.

**#107 Taiping Rebellion (1850-1864), T1 heterodox.** Hong Xiuquan, a failed examination candidate influenced by Christian teaching, believed himself the son of God and younger brother of Jesus, sent to reform China; the rebellion ravaged 17 provinces and cost about 20 million lives ([Britannica, Taiping Rebellion](https://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/580815/Taiping-Rebellion) [R]). Hong's mentor, the Baptist Issachar Roberts, refused to baptise him and later called his toleration a farce; most deaths came from famine and disease, and estimates run from 20-30 million to far higher ([Wikipedia, Taiping Rebellion](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiping_Rebellion) [W]). Charles Gordon's Ever-Victorious Army helped the Qing, though Britannica judges its role not decisive ([Britannica, Charles George Gordon](https://www.britannica.com/biography/Charles-George-Gordon) [R]). This is the deadliest conflict in the compilation with a Christian-derived ideology at its core, fought against a non-Christian state and opposed in the end by Western Christian powers.

**#108-109 Crimean and Russo-Turkish wars (1853-1878), T4 and T3.** The Crimean War grew out of a dispute between Catholic France and Orthodox Russia over privileges at the Holy Places and Russia's claim to protect the Sultan's Orthodox subjects, yet Christian Britain and France fought beside the Ottomans; about 250,000 died on each side, largely from disease ([Britannica, Crimean War](https://www.britannica.com/event/Crimean-War) [R]). In 1877 Pan-Slav pressure after the Bulgarian atrocities pushed Alexander II into war, though Bruce Menning stresses mixed strategic motives ([Menning, Encyclopedia of Modern Europe](https://encyclopedia.com/history/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/russo-turkish-war) [R]); the tsar's self-styled role as Orthodox protector and Russian losses of up to 200,000 are **[W-only]** ([Timewise Traveller](https://www.timewisetraveller.co.uk/russo.html) [W]).

**#110-112 Buganda, Sudan and the Boxers (1881-1901).** In Buganda, Protestant and Catholic converts deposed the Kabaka in 1888; Muslims briefly proclaimed an Islamic state; in 1892 Protestant and Catholic factions fought, and Lugard's Maxim gun decided it for the pro-British Protestants (T2 / BS) ([LOC Country Study, Uganda](https://countrystudies.us/uganda/5.htm) [R]; [Britannica, Buganda](https://www.britannica.com/place/Buganda) [R]). Gordon, of "an unorthodox, mystical brand of Christianity", died at Khartoum in 1885 and was hailed as a martyred warrior-saint ([Britannica, Gordon](https://www.britannica.com/biography/Charles-George-Gordon) [R]); at Omdurman (1898) about 10,000 Mahdists and 48 British soldiers were killed ([HistoryNet, Lacey on Omdurman](https://www.historynet.com/what-we-learned-from-omdurman/) [R]), and four chaplains of different churches led a memorial service for Gordon at Khartoum two days later ([Royal Collection Trust, Gordon memorial service](https://col.rct.uk/collection/407433/the-memorial-service-for-general-gordon-4-september-1898) [R]). The Christian element on the British side was commemorative (T4). The Boxers (AC) attacked missionaries and Chinese Christians from 1899, besieged the legations and Beijing's cathedral, and were crushed by an eight-power force; deaths reached 100,000 or more, mostly civilians, including about 200-250 foreigners and thousands of Chinese Christians ([Britannica, Boxer Rebellion](https://www.britannica.com/event/Boxer-Rebellion) [R]).

## 1900 to November 2026: from holy war to communal banner

After 1900 explicit, actor-documented Christian invocation survives in a small set of cases: the Cristeros, Spain's bishops, the Iron Guard, the LRA, US anti-abortion terrorism and the Russian Orthodox hierarchy. In most other conflicts "Christian" labels a community, and monitors and scholars locate the causes in land, ethnicity and state power. Political scientists confirm the shift in kind: Nilsson and Svensson find that government-rebel conflicts over religious claims rose from 3% (1975) to 55% (2015), driven mainly by Islamist aspirations, while identity-only conflicts such as Northern Ireland have become rarer ([Nilsson and Svensson 2018, Political Violence at a Glance](https://politicalviolenceataglance.org/2018/05/23/what-we-know-and-dont-know-about-religious-civil-wars/) [S]; [RELAC dataset record, JCR 2018](https://relbib.de/Record/1577722876/Description) [S]); Monica Toft's civil-war dataset also finds religious cleavages increasingly central ([Toft 2021, PRIO](https://www.prio.org/publications/13045) [S]).

**#113 Cristero War (1926-1929; 1934-1940), T1 popular / AC.** Catholic rebels rose in August 1926 against President Calles's penal code targeting the Church, under the cry "¡Viva Cristo Rey!", and laid down arms on 21 June 1929 after a Church-state agreement; Jean Meyer estimates about 90,000 casualties, and in the second rising (1934-1940) Cristero bands assaulted or killed at least 100 socialist teachers ([Americas Quarterly, Kloppe-Santamaría and Young](https://americasquarterly.org/article/the-long-shadow-of-mexicos-war-over-catholicism/) [R]). The 2026 centenary is being marked in Mexico ([El Imparcial column](https://www.elimparcial.com/tij/columnas/2026/08/01/cien-anos-de-la-cristiada-1926-2026/) [W], title-level).

**#114 Iron Guard (1927-1941), T3.** Codreanu's Legion of the Archangel Michael combined fascist, Nazi and Orthodox-mystical elements on a Christian-nationalist platform; its January 1941 rebellion and pogrom killed about 120 Jews in Bucharest and 30 elsewhere ([Encyclopaedia Judaica, Iron Guard](https://www.encyclopedia.com/reference/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/iron-guard) [R]).

**#115 Spanish Civil War (1936-1939), T1 episcopal / AC.** A September 1936 episcopal pastoral called the war a "Crusade for religion, for the fatherland, for civilisation", and the bishops' collective letter of 1 July 1937, signed by 48 prelates but not by the cardinal of Tarragona or the bishop of Vitoria, rallied world Catholic opinion for Franco while largely avoiding the word. On the Republican side almost 7,000 clergy and religious were killed, 2,894 of them in the first six weeks, per Julián Casanova ([Spain Then and Now](https://www.spainthenandnow.com/spanish-history/civil-war-and-the-catholic-church) [W], citing [S]). **[W-only]** in this compilation; Preston's repression totals and the overall death toll were not verified.

**#116 Independent State of Croatia (1941-1945), T3.** The Ustaša regime ran compulsory conversion of Orthodox Serbs to Catholicism, with refusal often meaning death ([Jewish Virtual Library, Jasenovac](https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jasenovac-camp) [R]). USHMM, which describes the Ustaša as fanatically nationalist, fascist and terrorist, estimates **77,000-99,000** murdered at Jasenovac and **320,000-340,000** Serbs killed across Croatia and Bosnia, warns the figures are highly uncertain, and does not discuss the clergy ([USHMM, Jasenovac](https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/jasenovac) [R]); the Jewish Virtual Library gives 330,000-390,000 Serbs. The role of Archbishop Stepinac and individual Franciscans is contested between Serbian Orthodox and Croatian Catholic advocacy sources, both [W].

**#117 Sudan's civil wars (1955-1972; 1983-2005), T3.** Nationwide Sharia in 1983 and a 1992 jihad against the Nuba, with a fatwa declaring even Nuba Muslims apostates, gave the war a religious edge; the Tufts World Peace Foundation estimates roughly 1-2 million civilian deaths in 1983-2005, mostly from starvation and disease, and at least 100,000 from direct violence ([Tufts WPF, Mass Atrocity Endings](https://sites.tufts.edu/atrocityendings/?p=52) [S]). The southern side's Christian identity is a communal marker more than a war aim.

**#118-119 Biafra and Rhodesia (1964-1979), T4.** N. I. Omenka argues the Nigeria-Biafra War had political, ethnic, social and economic causes but was "unduly cast as a religious war", a framing Biafra and its Western supporters promoted for relief fundraising ([Omenka 2010, Journal of African History](https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-african-history/article/abs/blaming-the-gods-christian-religious-propaganda-in-the-nigeriabiafra-war/AB81B380010028B6656AFB0D53612B59) [S]); deaths are put at 500,000 to 3 million ([Britannica, Nigerian civil war](https://www.britannica.com/topic/Nigerian-civil-war) [R]). Ian Smith's regime claimed to defend "Western Christian civilization", yet the nationalist leadership held more Christians than his cabinet and the churches largely opposed him ([Lutterworth Press, Christian and Cultural Warfare in Rhodesia, ch. 1](https://www.lutterworth.com/wp-content/uploads/extracts/christian-warfare-ch1.pdf) [S]).

**#120 The Troubles (1969-1998), T3 / BS.** The Sutton Index records 3,532 deaths from July 1969 to 2001: 2,058 caused by republicans, 1,027 by loyalists and 366 by British forces, including 130 deliberate IRA sectarian killings of Protestant civilians ([CAIN, Sutton Index](https://cain.ulster.ac.uk/sutton/book) [R]). The paramilitaries organised on national-constitutional lines; Catholic and Protestant were community labels.

**#121 Ilaga (c. 1970-1971), T3.** More than 70 Muslims were killed in a mosque at Manili on 19 June 1971, an attack attributed to Ilaga, described as a paramilitary group working with the Constabulary against Moro insurgency ([UP Diliman, Manili massacre](https://oica.upd.edu.ph/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/02_UPDOR2024_Manili_Massacre.pdf) [R]). Its Ilonggo Christian settler base, folk-Catholic amulets and a tally of 518 dead in 21 massacres are **[W-only]** ([Wikipedia, Ilaga](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilaga) [W]).

**#122 Lebanese Civil War (1975-1990), T3 / BS.** About 150,000 died; the Lebanese Forces united Christian militias against the PLO and its allies, with Israeli training and supplies, but MERIP stresses that religious labels marked sectarian and territorial loyalties, that the fiercest fights often pitted members of one sect against each other, and that the core issues were inequality and power ([MERIP, primer on Lebanon's war](https://merip.org/1990/01/primer-lebanons-15-year-war-1975-1990/) [R]). At Sabra and Shatila (16-18 September 1982) the Maronite Lebanese Forces under Elie Hobeika killed between 460 (Lebanese inquiry) and about 2,000 (Palestinian Red Crescent) people, with Israel's Kahan Commission at 700-800 ([Encyclopedia.com, Sabra and Shatila](https://encyclopedia.com/international/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/sabra-and-shatila) [R]).

**#123 and #126 Northeast India (1980-2024), T3.** The NSCN, founded on 31 January 1980, is summarised as basing its manifesto on socialism and a spiritual outlook of "Nagaland for Christ"; the manifesto text itself was not retrieved; a 1997 ceasefire holds ([GlobalSecurity, NSCN](https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/para/nscn.htm) [R]), and talks remained deadlocked in October 2026 over a separate flag and constitution ([Telangana Today, 15 October 2026](https://telanganatoday.com/editorial-fresh-hope-for-naga-settlement) [R]). Claims that Baptists armed Tripura's NLFT and that it killed Hindus for refusing conversion rest on police statements and Hindu-nationalist outlets; the insurgency ended in a September 2024 accord ([Wikipedia, NLFT](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Liberation_Front_of_Tripura) [W]). **[W-only]**.

**#124 Holy Spirit Movement and Lord's Resistance Army (1986-present), T1 syncretic, contested.** Tim Allen places Alice Lakwena among spirit mediums who drew on Christian moral ideas and Catholic-linked divination amid state collapse ([Allen 1991, Africa](https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/africa/article/abs/understanding-alice-ugandas-holy-spirit-movement-in-context/DE89E3724443D29715DE5303EC10CE5B) [S]). Specialists call the claim that the LRA seeks rule by the Ten Commandments misleading out of context: its blend of Christian and Acholi beliefs was "effectively used to legitimize the movement", and by the late 1990s Kony sought to be feared as a soldier more than revered as a prophet ([IWG-LRA Diagnostic Study, World Bank](https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/298391468148513539/pdf/651970WP0LRA0d00Box361556B00PUBLIC0.pdf) [R]); Allen and Vlassenroot's volume aims beyond the "bible-quoting psychopath" stereotype ([LUCAS Leeds, review of The LRA: Myth and Reality](https://lucas.leeds.ac.uk/review/the-lords-resistance-army-myth-and-reality/) [S]). The UN attributes more than 100,000 deaths, 60,000-100,000 child abductions and 2.5 million displaced to the LRA since 1987 ([Gulf Times/AFP, UN report 2013](https://www.gulf-times.com/story/353445/konys-lra-has-killed-more-than-100000-un) [R]). By September 2025 the last group had fewer than 100 members and no documented abductions since mid-2024 ([Invisible Children, The LRA's Final Chapter](https://invisiblechildren.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/The-LRAs-Final-Chapter-September-2025.pdf) [R]); on 6 November 2025 the ICC confirmed all 39 charges against Kony in absentia, though trial requires his arrest ([GlobalSecurity, ICC release reprint](https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/news/2025/11/mil-251106-icc01.htm) [R]).

**#125 Armenia-Azerbaijan (1988-2023), T3.** Altay Goyushov shows the Azerbaijani state deploying Islamic ritual and rhetoric in 2020 mainly to control religious discourse and win allies, in a war he treats as territorial ([Goyushov, CNRS Observatoire des religions](https://obsreligion.cnrs.fr/?p=2209) [S]); US Christian advocacy framed Artsakh's fall as persecution of Christians ([Christianity Today, September 2023](https://www.christianitytoday.com/news/2023/september/nagorno-karabakh-war-artsakh-armenia-christian-advocacy.html) [W], title-level).

**#127 Yugoslav wars and Bosnia (1991-1995), T3 contested.** Michael Sells argues that Bosnian Muslims were "selected for destruction because of their religion" under *Christoslavism*, the idea that Slavs are Christian by nature; the reviewer István Deák largely accepts this while noting ordinary Serbs resisted more than clergy did ([New Republic, Deák on Sells](https://newrepublic.com/article/63709/god-their-sides) [S]). Video shows Serbian Orthodox priests blessing weapons used around Srebrenica and the guns that shelled Sarajevo ([IPS, 2009](https://www.ipsnews.net/?p=38217) [R]). The ICTY estimates 7,000-8,000 men and boys killed at Srebrenica ([USHMM, Srebrenica](https://www.ushmm.org/confront-genocide/cases/bosnia-herzegovina/srebrenica/violence) [R]) and the Sarajevo research centre counted at least 97,207 dead in Bosnia ([Dawn/AFP 2007](https://www.dawn.com/news/252819/97-000-killed-in-bosnian-war-study) [R]). Most scholars treat the war as ethno-nationalist with religion as identity marker; Sells holds the influential minority view.

**#128 US anti-abortion and Christian Identity violence (1990s-2010s), T1 individual.** Eric Rudolph's 2005 plea statement, claiming the 1996 Olympic Park bombing and attacks on clinics and a lesbian bar, argues from scripture: "Because I believe that abortion is murder, I also believe that force is justified" ([NPR, Rudolph statement](https://www.npr.org/2005/04/14/4600480/full-text-of-eric-rudolphs-confession) [P]). Its theology is anti-abortion Christianity, with no Christian Identity content. The Oklahoma City bomber's links to the Elohim City compound are contested: the FBI found no conspirators beyond Terry Nichols ([Herald-Standard/AP 2003](https://www.heraldstandard.com/news/2003/feb/13/after-okc-bombing-fbi-found-link-to-group/) [R]). Seven members of the Christian-based Hutaree militia were acquitted of seditious conspiracy in 2012 ([Al Jazeera 2012](https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2012/3/28/christian-militia-acquitted-of-sedition-in-us) [R]).

**#129-130 and #133 Rhetoric and lone attackers (2001-2019), T4.** George W. Bush said on 16 September 2001, "This crusade, this war on terrorism, is going to take awhile", and in 2004 said he regretted the word ([Dawn 2004](https://www.dawn.com/news/398257/bush-regrets-invoking-crusade-after-911) [R]). Breivik, who killed 77 in 2011, called for a "Knights Templar" army ([SPLC Intelligence Report 2011](https://www.splcenter.org/get-informed/intelligence-report/browse-all-issues/2011/fall/christian-crusader) [R], advocacy NGO) and called himself "100 percent Christian" while admitting no personal faith ([The Week, Breivik roundup](https://theweek.com/articles/482714/terrorism-anders-breivik-christian) [R]). The Christchurch attacker, who killed 51 worshippers in 2019 ([Al Jazeera 2020](https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/12/8/new-zealand-2) [R]), inscribed crusade and siege dates on his rifles ([CBS News](https://www.cbsnews.com/news/new-zealand-shooting-gunman-rifles-white-supremacist-symbols-memes) [R]), imagery historians call a far-right myth ([MaltaToday](https://www.maltatoday.com.mt/news/national/93667/malta_1565_inscription_on_terror_attack_rifle_shows_how_great_siege_is_appropriated_by_far_right) [R]). A check of 2025-2026 news found **no confirmed attack committed explicitly in Christ's name**: CSIS reports no Christian invocation in the May 2026 San Diego mosque shooting ([CSIS, 19 May 2026](https://www.csis.org/analysis/san-diego-mosque-shooting-marks-deadly-first-united-states) [R]).

**#131 Anti-balaka, Central African Republic (2013-present), T3.** Anti-balaka groups began as anti-bandit self-defence; after the mostly Muslim Séléka seized power in 2013 they retaliated against Muslim communities, and Ludovic Lado argues religion "should not be overestimated" in an essentially political conflict ([Lado, Wilson Center 2014](https://www.wilsoncenter.org/blog-post/what-is-religious-about-the-conflict-in-central-african-republic) [R]). Amnesty documented ethnic cleansing of Muslims by this "largely Christian" force, including over 100 killed at Bossemptele in January 2014 ([Amnesty UK](https://www.amnesty.org.uk/central-african-republic-crisis-ethnic-cleansing) [R]); the UN Commission of Inquiry's conservative count is 3,000-6,000 killed in 2013-2014, and USHMM notes religion had not previously divided the country ([USHMM, CAR](https://www.ushmm.org/fr/genocide-prevention/countries/central-african-republic/political-and-ethnic-violence) [R]). In July 2025 the ICC convicted anti-balaka leaders Yekatom and Ngaïssona ([HRW World Report 2026, CAR](https://www.hrw.org/fr/world-report/2026/country-chapters/central-african-republic) [R]); anti-balaka do not appear as a distinct active force in 2025-2026 monitor reporting ([UN News, February 2026](https://news.un.org/en/story/2026/02/1167036) [R]).

**#132 Nigeria's Middle Belt and US action (c. 2001-present), T3 / T4.** HRW describes decades of violence between mainly Christian farmers and mainly Muslim herders, increasingly described in religious terms but rooted in land and resources, with 1,078 deaths recorded in January-March 2018 ([HRW 2018](https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/06/28/nigeria-rising-toll-middle-belt-violence) [R]); Crisis Group told Congress the conflicts are "not primarily religious in nature" and found no solid evidence for an Islamisation plot ([ICG testimony 2017](https://humanrightscommission.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/humanrightscommission.house.gov/files/documents/EJ%20Hogendoorn%20Testimony-%20ICG.pdf) [R]). On 31 October 2025 President Trump redesignated Nigeria a Country of Particular Concern, writing that "Christianity is facing an existential threat in Nigeria", a framing experts called largely inaccurate ([Al Jazeera, 31 October 2025](https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/10/31/trump-places-nigeria-on-watch-list-over-claims-of-anti-christian-violence) [R]); on 25 December 2025 US strikes hit Islamic State forces in Sokoto State, justified as protecting Christians, while Nigeria said victims were of many faiths ([PBS/AP](https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/u-s-launches-strike-against-islamic-state-forces-in-nigeria-trump-says) [R]). Christian advocacy groups call the violence genocide ([CSI-USA](https://csi-usa.org/fulani-militants-kill-20-christians-in-nigerias-middle-belt-in-one-week/) [W], title-level). The US action is a state using force framed as protecting Christians, a new category that the evidence supports as framing only.

**#134 Tigray (2020-2022), T4 / BS.** Orthodox Christians were both perpetrators and victims, and the war threatened to split the Ethiopian Orthodox Church; a massacre at Axum, the Orthodox holy city, was reported by AP ([AP via KSAT, February 2021](https://www.ksat.com/news/world/2021/02/18/horrible-witnesses-recall-massacre-in-ethiopian-holy-city/) [W], title-level). Death estimates range from under 100,000 (some Ethiopian officials) through up to 500,000 (Ghent University) to about 600,000 (AU envoy Obasanjo) ([The National, January 2023](https://thenationalnews.com/world/africa/2023/01/16/tigray-death-toll-could-be-as-high-as-600000-african-union-envoy-says) [R]).

**#135 Russia, Ukraine and the Russian Orthodox Church (2022-present), T1 church sacralisation / BS.** In September 2022 Patriarch Kirill told mobilising Russians that a soldier dying in duty makes a sacrifice that "washes away all the sins" he has committed ([RNS/AP, 27 September 2022](https://religionnews.com/2022/09/27/moscow-patriarch-russian-war-dead-have-their-sins-forgiven/) [R]), language that echoes the crusade indulgence. The World Russian People's Council, chaired by Kirill, decreed in March 2024 that "the Special Military Operation is a Holy War" and that all Ukraine belongs in Russia's exclusive sphere ([Atlantic Council, April 2024](https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/ukrainealert/russian-orthodox-church-declares-holy-war-against-ukraine-and-west/) [R], pro-Ukraine think-tank; decree text not fetched). Church figures report 42,000 soldiers baptised, 140 field churches and 2,000 priests sent to the front, and a suspended priest calls war "Russia's new civil religion" ([Moscow Times, February 2025 content](https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2026/07/23/training-the-warriors-of-victory-russian-orthodox-church-marks-3-years-of-war-in-ukraine) [R]); Kirill publicly mocked a priest who questioned the patriotic line ([Moscow Times, February 2025](https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2026/08/05/russian-patriarch-mocks-priest-for-questioning-churchs-patriotism) [R]). In March 2026 Metropolitan Kirill of Stavropol, responsible for relations with the armed forces, said Russia "will need to go further, occupying Odessa and Kiev", and an anti-war priest was jailed in Kazakhstan at the request of the church's local diocese ([Church Times, 6 March 2026](https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2026/13-march/news/world/russian-orthodox-leader-calls-on-russia-to-go-further-in-war-with-ukraine) [R]). Analysts still see the Church following the Kremlin more than driving the war; even so, this is the most explicit institutional holy-war framing by a major church since 1945, and it is ongoing at November 2026.


## Casualty figures: claims far outnumber counts

**Chroniclers inflated, and the inflation has a recognisable signature.** Medieval figures are round, triumphal and often scriptural, and they routinely exceed the population of the place concerned. At Jerusalem in 1099 Fulcher's nearly 10,000 and Ibn al-Athīr's 70,000-plus differ sevenfold, the Arabic figure grew in the retelling from no number to 3,000 to 70,000 and finally 100,000, and Hirschler cites Ibn Khaldūn's warning that such numbers are not to be taken literally ([Hirschler, SOAS](https://soas-repository.worktribe.com/OutputFile/347926) [S]). Even an apologetic writer notes that the "blood to the knees" imagery echoes Revelation 14:20 and that the city held perhaps 20,000-30,000 people ([Catholic Answers, The Massacre of Jerusalem](https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/the-massacre-of-jerusalem) [W]). The same pattern recurs across the compilation: the legate's 20,000 dead at Béziers against a town of at most about 10,000, with Tyerman judging the true figure far lower ([Bede's Journal blog, on Pinker](https://bedejournal.blogspot.com/2011/11/pinker-tackles-albigensian-crusade.html) [W], attributions to check); 50,000 killed or captured at Barbastro against fewer than 8,000 inhabitants; Peter of Dusburg's armies larger than the whole Prussian population; Altenesch's 2,000-11,000 against a Stedinger force of perhaps 2,000; Las Navas and Baeza at 60,000-100,000; and the 1641 Irish rising, where the government claimed 154,000 settler deaths against a modern estimate of perhaps 4,000 ([Britannica, English Civil Wars](https://www.Britannica.Com/event/English-Civil-Wars) [R]). Partisanship works in both directions: St Bartholomew's Day estimates run from 2,000 (a Catholic apologist) to 70,000 (the Huguenot Sully) ([Britannica, St Bartholomew's Day](https://www.britannica.com/event/Massacre-of-Saint-Bartholomews-Day) [R]). The report therefore quotes chronicle numbers only as claims attributed to their author.

**The Béziers "Kill them all" line is a late attribution.** The only source is Caesarius of Heisterbach, a Cistercian writing in Germany in 1219-1223, at least a decade after Béziers, who says only that the legate was reported to have said it; the crusade's own chronicler, Peter of les Vaux-de-Cernay, does not mention it, and Laurence Marvin concludes certainty is impossible though the words fit Amalric's character ([Wikipedia, Caedite eos](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caedite_eos._Novit_enim_Dominus_qui_sunt_eius.) [W], citing [S] work). Barber lists the episode among the historiographical clichés of the war ([Barber, via Medievalists.net](https://www.medievalists.net/2013/09/the-albigensian-crusades-wars-like-any-other/) [S]), and Britannica treats the words as alleged ([Britannica, Albigensian Crusade](https://www.britannica.com/event/Albigensian-Crusade) [R]). The defensible status is: attributed second-hand, unverifiable, plausible in spirit given Amalric's own boast of 20,000 dead.

**The popular "1 to 9 million crusade deaths" has no scholarly basis.** The circulating totals trace to 19th- and early-20th-century popular or polemical books: Mackay (1841) gives 2 million Europeans, Hittell (1874) 1 million, Robertson (1902), a rationalist critic of Christianity, 9 million, Elson (1921) 5 million, Garrison (1922) 3 million, Wertham (1966) 1 million and Matthew White (2012) 3 million, partly derived from one another and counting different populations; professional crusade historians decline to produce an aggregate ([Holt, Death estimates for the Crusades](https://apholt.com/2019/01/30/death-estimates-for-the-crusades/) [W]). That does not make the toll small. For the First Crusade alone, Riley-Smith's sample of 217 knights shows about 37% dying, Tyerman suggests a third of aristocrats and possibly 70-80% of lesser crusaders, John France gives an overall loss of three in four, and Jean Flori about two-thirds ([Holt, Casualty rates for First Crusade participants](https://apholt.com/2019/02/19/modern-scholars-on-the-casualty-rates-for-participants-of-the-first-crusade/) [W], summarising [S] works). For the Albigensian Crusade, Steven Pinker's 200,000 and White's 1 million sit against a regional population of about 1 million (Bede's Journal [W]). The honest position: heavy, unquantifiable losses, with campaign attrition from disease and famine exceeding battle deaths.

**Americas demography: disease dominated, conquest multiplied it.** UCL researchers calculated about **55 million Indigenous deaths in the 16th century** from epidemics, warfare and famine, enough to lower atmospheric carbon dioxide ([UCL Geography, Great Dying](https://www.ucl.ac.uk/geography/news/2019/feb/great-dying-1492-led-lower-co2-and-cooler-planet) [R]). Pre-contact population estimates run from Kroeber's 8.4 million to Dobyns's possibly over 100 million, with Denevan's consensus near 54 million and Henige criticising the high counts as products of arbitrary formulas; Noble David Cook stresses disease, Russell Thornton finds warfare comparatively minor overall, Jeffrey Ostler stresses colonial disruption, Andrés Reséndez makes enslavement the primary driver in Spanish territories, David Stannard's near-100 million is a contested high end, and a 2020 genetic study suggests Caribbean estimates may be tenfold too large ([Wikipedia, Population history of the Indigenous peoples of the Americas](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_history_of_the_Indigenous_peoples_of_the_Americas) [W], summarising [S] works). For central Mexico, Robert McCaa summarises how Cook and Borah's "demographic doom" was contested on data and method while defending a major 1520-1521 catastrophe ([McCaa 1995, University of Minnesota](https://users.pop.umn.edu/~rmccaa/noncuant/democat1.htm) [S]), and a Stanford working paper cites Cook and Borah for no more than 1.37 million survivors by 1605 ([Stanford working paper on pandemics in Mexico](https://web.stanford.edu/~saumitra/papers/Pandemics_and_Economic_Resilience_in_Mexico_wp.pdf) [S]), against an often-quoted 1.075 million that was not verified. The Christian justification of conquest bears most directly on the violent share (war, enslavement under just-war doctrine, forced labour), and those in turn raised epidemic mortality; disease-versus-violence is therefore a false dichotomy for most recent scholarship.

**Modern ranges are wide because they are political.** Estimates of Serbs killed by the Ustaša run from 25,000 to over a million, with the most reliable at 320,000-390,000 ([Jewish Virtual Library](https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jasenovac-camp) [R]; [USHMM](https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/jasenovac) [R]); Sabra and Shatila from 460 to 2,000; Biafra from 500,000 to 3 million; Tigray from under 100,000 to 600,000; and Sudan's "ubiquitous" 2.5 million rests largely on one researcher, Millard Burr ([Tufts WPF](https://sites.tufts.edu/atrocityendings/?p=52) [S]). Early-modern totals bundle combat with famine and plague: Britannica notes that modern scholarship has revised Thirty Years' War losses downward to 15-20% ([Britannica, Germany: Thirty Years' War](https://www.britannica.com/place/Germany/The-Thirty-Years-War-and-the-Peace-of-Westphalia) [R]), and the French wars' 2-4 million includes disease. The spread itself is a finding and is reported as such.

**The "share of wars that were religious" is a misused statistic.** The 123-of-1,763 figure is an index count with no analytic coding behind it; it neither proves nor disproves claims about religion and war; it carries no Christian-versus-other breakdown ([Holt, Counting religious wars](https://apholt.com/2018/12/26/counting-religious-wars-in-the-encyclopedia-of-wars/) [W]). Rigorous datasets distinguish religion as identity from religion as the issue at stake and cover only 1975 onward. On the historiographical poles, Rodney Stark's apologetic *God's Battalions* is criticised by a reviewer for relying on scholarship decades out of date ([Renick, Christian Century 2010](https://christiancentury.org/print/pdf/node/28626) [R]); Tyerman accepts sincere crusading piety while refusing apologetics and is faulted for uneven sympathy towards Muslims and Byzantines ([LRB review of Tyerman, God's War](https://www.lrb.co.uk/v29/n23/jl-nelson/eastern-promises) [R]); Karen Armstrong's argument that violence stems from states rather than religion is criticised for shifting definitions ([McBain, Cairo Review](https://www.thecairoreview.com/book-reviews/fields-of-blood/) [R]); and Philip Jenkins argues that violent scriptural texts rarely drive violence by themselves but must be owned by the churches ([Howell, Christian Century 2012](https://christiancentury.org/print/pdf/node/29540) [R]). The claim that religion causes most wars and the claim that Christianity's wars were defensive or marginal are both unsupported by this record.

## What remains unverified or rests only on [W]

The table lists every material claim that the notes flag as unverified, plus claims that rest only on weak sources. Items marked "omitted" were left out of the body text; items marked "[W-only]" appear in the body with that flag.

| Area | Claim | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Late antiquity | Chrysopolis religious details and 25,000-30,000 dead; Frigidus 10,000 Goths; Gothic War framing; Kaleb's campaign details | [W-only] |
| Late antiquity | Milvian Bridge casualties; Serapeum casualties and 391 vs 392 date; Council of Arles (314) canon on soldiers; Origen's "prayer" passage location | Unverified; omitted or noted |
| Early medieval | Covadonga, Clavijo, Avar wars, Slav revolt of 983, Koppány, Vata, Polish pagan reaction, Christianisation of Rus' | [W-only] |
| Early medieval | Verden debate (Nelson, Barbero, Becher, Hen); Alcuin's letters (AI-assisted translation); Fouracre on Tours; Liber Pontificalis figure of 375,000 at Tours | [W] / omitted (375,000) |
| Theology | Lateran III and IV indulgence provisions; Innocent III's *Quia maior* (1213) innovations; Bernard's Latin "malicide"; Gregory VII's *militia sancti Petri* wording | [W-only] / unverified, omitted |
| Eastern crusades | Bull title *Audita tremendi*; exact Hattin and Acre-execution dates; Zara excommunication; John Paul II's 2001/2004 apologies for 1204; Choniates on Saracen mercy; Cairo Geniza ransom letters | Unverified; omitted |
| Eastern crusades | Mahdia 1390; Holy League of 1684 membership and Karlowitz terms; bull name *Ezechielis prophetae*; Lepanto Rosary feast | [W-only] / unverified, omitted |
| Eastern crusades | WHE army sizes for the Second Crusade | [R], recheck |
| European crusades | Livonia, Prussia (assimilation debate), Lithuania, Grunwald figures, Swedish crusades, Neva and Lake Peipus | [W-only] or [W] beside [R] |
| European crusades | Las Navas casualty figures and the popular "25-30 Christian dead"; Granada "100,000 dead or enslaved"; Sixtus IV crusade bull titles | [W-only]; popular figure and bull titles omitted |
| European crusades | Albigensian totals (200,000-1 million); Tyerman and Costen on Béziers; Montségur 210 burned | [W]; attributions to check |
| European crusades | Drenthe, Bosnia, Aragon, Dolcino, Despenser; Clement V's anti-Dolcino bull; salt sown at Palestrina | [W-only]; bull and salt omitted |
| European crusades | Kutná Hora mine shafts and Žižka's lime kiln; 1,600 Kutná Hora victims and bounties | [W-only]; 1,600 omitted |
| Reformation era | Count's Feud; Cologne War; Prayer Book Rebellion and its 4,000-5,500 toll; Huguenot rebellions' 100,000; Morrill's "last of the Wars of Religion" | [W-only]; 4,000-5,500 omitted |
| Reformation era | Origin of the 2-4 million French figure; Desmond famine toll (30,000); Armada's "1 million ducats"; Solovetsky defender numbers; Shimabara heads and banner | Unverified; omitted or flagged |
| Colonial | Canary crusade bulls and genocide reading; Taíno population range; Mixtón; Castilian War; Ethiopian-Adal War; Siberia; Goa Inquisition; Greek massacres; Circassian toll | [W-only] |
| Colonial | Cook and Borah's 25.2 million (1518) and 1.075 million (1605); De Soto reading the *Requerimiento* (WHE, likely garbled) | Unverified; omitted |
| Modern | Spanish bishops' "Crusade" pastoral and clergy death toll (rests on an educational site citing Casanova); Preston's repression totals | [W-only]; totals omitted |
| Modern | Ustaše: Budak's "thirds" slogan, about 240,000 forced conversions, Stepinac's 1946 conviction and 1998 beatification | Unverified; omitted |
| Modern | NLFT religious claims; Ilaga's Christian symbolism; NSCN manifesto text (only a secondary summary seen) | [W-only] / secondary only |
| Modern | HSM practices (holy oil, "stones into grenades"); ICTY and ICJ genocide judgments; Croatian Catholic symbolism in 1991-1995; Damour massacre toll; Yugoslav war total | Unverified; omitted |
| Modern | Rudolph's "Army of God" letters; Christian Identity label for Elohim City; Christchurch manifesto's view of Christianity; April 2026 correspondents' dinner suspect's church | Unverified; omitted |
| Modern | WCC statement on the ROC decree; Axum massacre; Christian advocacy on Karabakh and Nigeria | Title-level [W] |
| Modern | East Timor as a Christian-banner conflict | No evidence; excluded |
| Modern | Casualties of the December 2025 US strikes in Nigeria; total Russia-Ukraine casualties | Unknown; not retrieved |

## Conclusion

The record reframes the question. Holy war in the strict sense is a bounded invention with a known birth and a long decline: Latin popes first promised heaven to fallen soldiers in the 9th century, institutionalised the promise in 1095, turned it on heretics and fellow Christians by the early 13th century, and wrote it into the legal title to the Americas. Its signature move, remission of sins for dying in battle, was refused outright by Constantinople in the 960s, which makes Patriarch Kirill's 2022 assurance that death at the front washes away sins, and his council's 2024 "Holy War" decree, a striking reversal: the Orthodox world now hosts the clearest institutional holy-war language of the 21st century. Lethality and doctrinal clarity also run in opposite directions. The best-documented crusades have modest, inflated, chronicle-based tolls, while the entries with the largest death counts (the 16th-century Americas, the Thirty Years' War, the Taiping) are those where religion fused with state-building, heterodoxy or demographic catastrophe, and where famine and disease did most of the killing. "How many died in Christ's name" therefore has no single defensible answer; "which institutions licensed violence, and with what promises" does.

The evidence map points to where the compilation is weakest and where the label is migrating. The medieval core rests on primary texts and specialist scholarship; the [W-only] residue clusters at the margins (the early medieval north and east, the Baltic, colonial peripheries, Indian insurgencies), which is where further work would most change the picture. In the modern cases, the Christian framing is increasingly supplied by third parties (advocacy networks, foreign governments, the 2025 US redesignation and strikes in Nigeria) rather than by combatants, while monitors on the ground keep finding land, power and revenge. Readers should treat any future claim of a "war for Christianity" by testing who is making the claim, what document licenses the violence, and whether the casualty figure is a count or a boast.

## Bibliography

Sources are numbered in order of first citation and grouped by the section where they first appear. Each carries its quality label: [P] primary, [S] scholarly, [R] reference, [W] weak or unverified. Notes in parentheses flag hosts, translations or title-level access.


### Method, corrections and source-quality frameworks

1. [W] Wikipedia, Admiralty code. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Admiralty_code>
2. [R] CSU Chico, CRAAP test. <https://library.csuchico.edu/sites/default/files/craap-test.pdf>
3. [W] Wikipedia, Stedinger Crusade. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stedinger_Crusade>
4. [R] USHMM, Jasenovac. <https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/jasenovac>
5. [R] WHE, Second Crusade. <https://www.worldhistory.org/Second_Crusade/>
6. [W] Holt, Counting religious wars (credentialled crusade historian's blog summarising published scholarship). <https://apholt.com/2018/12/26/counting-religious-wars-in-the-encyclopedia-of-wars/>
7. [P] Vatican, homily of 12 March 2000. <https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/homilies/2000/documents/hf_jp-ii_hom_20000312_pardon.html>

### Theology and the counter-tradition

8. [S] Davis 1949, Blackfriars. <https://core-prod.cambridgecore.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/DEAEEA0F8147AE09FB1AF8283D9BB066/S1754201400034809a.pdf/the-early-christian-attitude-to-war.pdf>
9. [W] First Things, Anderson 2010. <https://firstthings.com/were-the-church-fathers-pacifists/>
10. [R] IEP, Just War Theory. <https://iep.utm.edu/justwar/>
11. [P] Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II q.40. <https://www.newadvent.org/summa/3040.htm>
12. [P] Augustine, Letter 93. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1102093.htm>
13. [P] Augustine, Letter 185. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1102185.htm>
14. [S] Winroth 2022, Cambridge History of Medieval Canon Law. <https://core-prod.cambridgecore.org/core/books/cambridge-history-of-medieval-canon-law/just-war-and-crusades/8C78979F9E5A6D07D5EE89FF3F546E07>
15. [S] Muldoon 1980, The Americas. <https://cambridge.org/core/journals/americas/article/john-wyclif-and-the-rights-of-the-infidels-the-requerimiento-reexamined/0D2712477AA1CD583F34DC6CC9D0235C>
16. [R] Britannica, Peace of God. <https://www.britannica.com/topic/Peace-of-God>
17. [S] Princeton UP, Erdmann. <https://press.princeton.edu/node/6288>
18. [R] Latham 2025, Medievalists.net. <https://www.medievalists.net/2025/07/how-the-crusade-became-a-medieval-institution/>
19. [P] Colorado War and Society Sourcebook. <https://colorado.pressbooks.pub/warandsocietysourcebook/chapter/pre-crusades-forgiveness-of-sin-for-fighting-wars/>
20. [P] Ott, Letters of Alexander II. <https://web.pdx.edu/~ott/hst399/Alexanderletters>
21. [R] Britannica, Crusades. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Crusades>
22. [P] Fordham, Urban II five versions. <https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/urban2-5vers.asp>
23. [P] Bernard, De laude novae militiae, ORB. <https://www.the-orb.arlima.net/encyclop/religion/monastic/bernard.html>
24. [W] Wikipedia, Crusading movement. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusading_movement>
25. [S] Morris 1988, BMGS. <https://cambridge.org/core/journals/byzantine-and-modern-greek-studies/article/two-faces-of-nikephoros-phokas/606BB35357FFB37017D1E97ADDB9F122>
26. [S] Vienna, Byzantinische Kriegsideologie abstracts. <https://byzneo.univie.ac.at/fileadmin/user_upload/i_byzneo/Plakate_und_Programme/Abstracts_Kriegsideologie.pdf>
27. [W] romanletters.org, Alcuin Letter 7 (AI-assisted translation, no Latin original given). <https://romanletters.org/letters/alcuin_york/7/>
28. [S] Tolan 2008, via Medievalists.net. <https://www.medievalists.net/2012/10/the-friar-and-the-sultan-francis-of-assisis-mission-to-egypt/>
29. [W] Wikipedia, Paweł Włodkowic. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pawe%C5%82_W%C5%82odkowic>
30. [R] FU Berlin, Erasmus exhibition catalogue. <https://refubium.fu-berlin.de/bitstream/handle/fub188/35224/Erasmus%20-%20%27War%20is%20sweet%20to%20those%20who%20have%20no%20experience%20of%20it%20%E2%80%A6%27%20-%20Protest%20against%20Violence%20and%20War.pdf>
31. [P] Schleitheim Confession. <https://anabaptists.org/history/schleith.html>
32. [P] Quaker Declaration to Charles II. <https://quaker.org/legacy/minnfm/peace/A%20Declaration%20to%20Charles%20II%201660.htm>
33. [W] Vatican News, WCC statement (title-level only). <https://vaticannews.va/en/world/news/2024-04/wcc-russia-decree-war-ukraine-statement.html>

### Late antiquity and the early Middle Ages

34. [R] Britannica, Milvian Bridge. <https://www.britannica.com/topic/Battle-of-Milvian-Bridge>
35. [W] Wikipedia, Battle of Chrysopolis. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Chrysopolis>
36. [R] Encyclopaedia Romana, Serapeum. <https://penelope.uchicago.edu/~grout/encyclopaedia_romana/greece/paganism/serapeum.html>
37. [R] Britannica, Donatists. <https://www.britannica.com/topic/Donatists>
38. [S] Beaver 1935, Church History. <https://cambridge.org/core/journals/church-history/article/donatist-circumcellions/4A25F506BB2212BFBB64345EB369DD4D>
39. [W] Wikipedia, Battle of the Frigidus. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Frigidus>
40. [S] Marzo 2020. <https://www.ceeol.com/search/article-detail?id=927239>
41. [P] Gregory of Tours, Histories II, Fordham. <https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/gregory-clovisconv.asp>
42. [S] Kaegi 1965, Traditio. <https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/traditio/article/arianism-and-the-byzantine-army-in-africa-533546/A6A4A7B40AF1A26A321E616A177E93D1>
43. [W] Wikipedia, Gothic War. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gothic_War_(535%E2%80%93554)>
44. [W] Wikipedia, Kaleb of Axum. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaleb_of_Axum>
45. [W] JMIH article title (title-level only). <https://journals.ekb.eg/article_349948.html>
46. [R] Medievalists.net, Theotokis on the True Cross. <https://www.medievalists.net/2019/04/true-cross-byzantine-sassanid-wars/>
47. [W] Wikipedia, Battle of Covadonga. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Covadonga>
48. [W] Wikipedia, Battle of Clavijo. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Clavijo>
49. [R] Britannica, Battle of Tours. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Battle-of-Tours-732>
50. [W] 1440 Review. <https://1440review.com/2023/10/14/the-battle-of-tours>
51. [P] Capitulary for Saxony, Fordham. <https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/carol-saxony.asp>
52. [W] Wikipedia, Massacre of Verden. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacre_of_Verden>
53. [W] Wikipedia, Avar Wars. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avar_Wars>
54. [R] WHE, Nikephoros II Phokas. <https://www.worldhistory.org/Nikephoros_II_Phokas/>
55. [W] Wikipedia, Slavic revolt of 983. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavic_revolt_of_983>
56. [W] Wikipedia, Christianization of Kievan Rus'. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianization_of_Kievan_Rus%27>
57. [W] Wikipedia, Koppány. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kopp%C3%A1ny>
58. [W] Wikipedia, Vata pagan uprising. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vata_pagan_uprising>
59. [W] Wikipedia, Pagan reaction in Poland. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pagan_reaction_in_Poland>
60. [R] Christian History Institute, Dead Man Converting (confessional popular magazine). <https://christianhistoryinstitute.org/magazine/article/dead-man-converting>
61. [W] Wikipedia, Crusade of Barbastro. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusade_of_Barbastro>
62. [S] Echevarría, review of O'Callaghan. <https://reviews.history.ac.uk/review/344>

### Eastern crusades and anti-Ottoman wars

63. [P] Solomon bar Samson, Fordham. <https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/1096jews-mainz.asp>
64. [P] Fordham, Fall of Jerusalem. <https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/cde-jlem.asp>
65. [P] UWM, Muslim accounts trans. Gabrieli. <https://sites.uwm.edu/carlin/?p=1017>
66. [S] Hirschler, SOAS repository. <https://soas-repository.worktribe.com/OutputFile/347926>
67. [S] Kedar 2004, Hebrew University record. <https://cris.huji.ac.il/en/publications/the-jerusalem-massacre-of-july-1099-in-the-western-historiography/>
68. [S] Fudge 2023, Cambridge World History of Genocide. <https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-world-history-of-genocide/crusaders-and-mass-killing-at-jerusalem-in-1099/BD1CDB140A06062FEFC48756DAD78F4E>
69. [W] Holt on Riley-Smith (credentialled crusade historian's blog summarising published scholarship). <https://apholt.com/2016/06/08/jonathan-riley-smith-on-the-motivations-of-the-first-crusaders/>
70. [S] IHR review of Tyerman. <https://reviews.history.ac.uk/print/review/1153>
71. [R] Britannica, Sigurd I. <https://www.britannica.com/biography/Sigurd-I-Magnusson>
72. [P] Eugenius III, Fordham. <https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/eugene3-2cde.asp>
73. [R] Britannica, Era of the Second and Third Crusades. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Crusades/The-era-of-the-Second-and-Third-Crusades>
74. [R] Britannica, Templars. <https://www.britannica.com/topic/Templars>
75. [R] Britannica, Third Crusade. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Crusades/The-Third-Crusade>
76. [P] Itinerarium on Acre, Fordham. <https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/source/1191acre.asp>
77. [W] Medievalists.net on Stroik 2010 (undergraduate paper via aggregator). <https://www.medievalists.net/2011/07/22/the-massacre-at-acre-mark-of-a-blood-thirsty-king/>
78. [R] Britannica, Fourth Crusade. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Fourth-Crusade>
79. [P] Choniates, Fordham. <https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/source/choniates1.asp>
80. [R] Britannica, Children's Crusade. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Childrens-Crusade>
81. [R] Britannica, Fifth Crusade (page flagged as an AI-generated summary). <https://www.britannica.com/event/Crusades/The-Fifth-Crusade>
82. [R] WHE, Sixth Crusade. <https://www.worldhistory.org/Sixth_Crusade/>
83. [S] Jackson 1987, BSOAS. <https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/bulletin-of-the-school-of-oriental-and-african-studies/article/abs/crusades-of-123941-and-their-aftermath/7E0C25AFEC5EAA70E51CF478E72D0998>
84. [R] WHE, Seventh Crusade. <https://www.worldhistory.org/Seventh_Crusade/>
85. [R] Britannica, Pastoureaux. <https://www.britannica.com/topic/Pastoureaux>
86. [R] Jewish Encyclopedia, Pastoureaux (1906 edition; dated). <https://jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/11936-pastoureaux>
87. [R] WHE, Eighth Crusade. <https://www.worldhistory.org/Eighth_Crusade/>
88. [R] WHE, Siege of Acre 1291. <https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1267/the-siege-of-acre-1291-ce/>
89. [S] Carr 2011, Royal Holloway thesis. <https://rhul.elsevierpure.com/files/2816039/Final_Draft_1.5.pdf>
90. [R] Britannica, Peter I of Cyprus. <https://www.britannica.com/biography/Peter-I-king-of-Cyprus>
91. [R] Britannica, Amadeus VI. <https://www.britannica.com/biography/Amadeus-VI>
92. [W] WarHistory.org, Mahdia Crusade. <https://warhistory.org/article/mahdia-crusade-1390?amp=0>
93. [R] Britannica, Battle of Nicopolis. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Battle-of-Nicopolis>
94. [R] Britannica, Battle of Varna. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Battle-of-Varna>
95. [S] Visy 2020, Pécs. <https://journals.lib.pte.hu/index.php/pontes/article/download/3394/3173/6361>
96. [R] Britannica, John of Capistrano. <https://www.britannica.com/biography/Saint-John-of-Capistrano>
97. [R] New Catholic Encyclopedia, Pius II. <https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/pius-ii-pope>
98. [R] Britannica, Battle of Lepanto. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Battle-of-Lepanto>
99. [R] Britannica, Siege of Vienna 1683. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Siege-of-Vienna-1683>
100. [W] Wikipedia, Holy League 1684. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holy_League_(1684)>

### Crusades within Europe

101. [S] Barber, Wars Like Any Other?, De Re Militari. <https://deremilitari.org/?p=1090>
102. [R] Latham, What were the Northern Crusades?. <https://www.medievalists.net/2019/02/what-were-the-northern-crusades/>
103. [P] Bernard, letter on the Wendish crusade, trans. James (translation by B. S. James on a non-academic host). <https://www.jassa.org/?p=12346>
104. [W] Wikipedia, Wendish Crusade. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wendish_Crusade>
105. [W] Wikipedia, Livonian Crusade. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Livonian_Crusade>
106. [R] Britannica, Teutonic Order. <https://www.britannica.com/topic/Teutonic-Order>
107. [W] Wikipedia, Prussian Crusade. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prussian_Crusade>
108. [W] Wikipedia, Lithuanian Crusade. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithuanian_Crusade>
109. [W] Wikipedia, Battle of Grunwald. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Grunwald>
110. [W] Wikipedia, First Swedish Crusade. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Swedish_Crusade>
111. [W] Wikipedia, Second Swedish Crusade. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Swedish_Crusade>
112. [W] Wikipedia, Third Swedish Crusade. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Swedish_Crusade>
113. [W] Wikipedia, Battle on the Ice. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_on_the_Ice>
114. [R] O'Callaghan, New Catholic Encyclopedia, Calatrava. <https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/calatrava-order>
115. [W] Wikipedia, Order of Santiago. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Order_of_Santiago>
116. [W] Wikipedia, Las Navas de Tolosa. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Las_Navas_de_Tolosa>
117. [W] Wikipedia, Crusade bull. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusade_bull>
118. [R] Bridwell Library, Spanish indulgence. <https://bridwell.omeka.net/exhibits/show/luther/antecedents/spanishindulgence>
119. [W] Wikipedia, Granada War. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Granada_War>
120. [R] Britannica, Albigensian Crusade. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Albigensian-Crusade>
121. [W] Wikipedia, Caedite eos. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caedite_eos._Novit_enim_Dominus_qui_sunt_eius.>
122. [S] Pegg, OUPblog. <https://blog.oup.com/2008/03/religious_violence/>
123. [W] Wikipedia, Siege of Montségur. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Monts%C3%A9gur>
124. [W] Wikipedia, Drenther Crusade. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drenther_Crusade>
125. [R] Britannica, Stedinger Crusade. <https://www.britannica.com/print/article/1386466>
126. [W] Wikipedia, Bosnian Crusade. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bosnian_Crusade>
127. [R] Catholic Encyclopedia 1909, Frederick II (1909-1912 Catholic Encyclopedia; dated and denominational). <https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06255a.htm>
128. [W] Wikipedia, Aragonese Crusade. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aragonese_Crusade>
129. [R] Schaff, History of the Christian Church VI (19th-century work; dated). <https://ccel.org/ccel/schaff/hcc6.ii.ii.ii.html>
130. [W] Wikipedia, Crusade against the Colonna. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusade_against_the_Colonna_family>
131. [W] Wikipedia, Fra Dolcino. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fra_Dolcino>
132. [W] Wikipedia, Despenser's Crusade. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Despenser%27s_Crusade>
133. [R] Britannica, Hussite Wars. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Hussite-Wars>
134. [W] Wikipedia, Hussite Wars. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hussite_Wars>
135. [W] AskHistorians, citing Fudge (forum answer citing Fudge 2016). <https://red.ks32.dev/r/AskHistorians/comments/1g5c4qf/is_the_papal_bull_omnium_plasmatoris_domini>
136. [R] Medievalists.net, summarising Fudge 2004. <https://www.medievalists.net/?p=23397>
137. [W] History of the Germans blog. <https://historyofthegermans.com/2025/01/zizka/>
138. [W] Lovecpokladu.cz. <https://www.lovecpokladu.cz/en/home/12-11-1420-zizka-conquered-prachatice-8286>

### Reformation-era wars

139. [S] Wilson, Rorotoko interview. <https://www.rorotoko.com/micro-interviews/20100423-wilson-peter-on-europe-tragedy-history-thirty-years-war-1>
140. [R] Britannica, Germany: Thirty Years' War. <https://www.britannica.com/place/Germany/The-Thirty-Years-War-and-the-Peace-of-Westphalia>
141. [R] Appleby, review of Cavanaugh, Commonweal. <https://commonwealmagazine.org/fire-sword>
142. [R] The Other Journal, review of Cavanaugh. <https://theotherjournal.com/2011/02/religion-and-its-discontents-a-review-of-the-myth-of-religious-violence/>
143. [R] Leithart on Holt, First Things. <https://firstthings.com/wars-of-decontamination/>
144. [R] Britannica, Revolution of 1525. <https://www.Britannica.Com/place/Germany/The-revolution-of-1525>
145. [R] WHE, German Peasants' War. <https://www.worldhistory.org/German_Peasants'_War/>
146. [R] Britannica, Zwingli. <https://www.britannica.com/biography/Huldrych-Zwingli>
147. [R] Canton of Aargau, Villmergen 1712. <https://www.ag.ch/de/themen/kultur-sport/kultur/kulturkanton/erinnerungskultur/villmergerkrieg-landfrieden-aarau-1712/geschichte-1712>
148. [R] Britannica, John of Leiden. <https://www.britannica.com/biography/John-of-Leiden>
149. [W] Wikipedia, European wars of religion. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_wars_of_religion>
150. [R] Britannica, Pilgrimage of Grace. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Pilgrimage-of-Grace>
151. [R] EBSCO, Schmalkaldic War. <https://ebsco.com/research-starters/history/schmalkaldic-war>
152. [R] Britannica, Peace of Augsburg. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Peace-of-Augsburg>
153. [W] Devon Perspectives, Part 1. <https://devonperspectives.co.uk/prayerbook_rebellion_1.html>
154. [W] Devon Perspectives, Part 2. <https://devonperspectives.co.uk/prayerbook_rebellion_2.html>
155. [W] Devon Perspectives, Part 5. <https://devonperspectives.co.uk/prayerbook_rebellion_5.html>
156. [R] Britannica, Wars of Religion. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Wars-of-Religion>
157. [R] Britannica, St Bartholomew's Day. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Massacre-of-Saint-Bartholomews-Day>
158. [S] Holt excerpt, unofficial host (scholarly text on an unofficial host). <https://www.harvestherald.com/sop/fwor.html>
159. [R] WHE, French Wars of Religion. <https://www.worldhistory.org/French_Wars_of_Religion/.md>
160. [R] Britannica, Eighty Years' War. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Eighty-Years-War>
161. [R] WHE, Eighty Years' War. <https://www.worldhistory.org/Eighty_Years'_War/.md>
162. [R] Encyclopedia of Irish History and Culture, Desmond Rebellions. <https://www.encyclopedia.com/international/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/desmond-rebellions>
163. [P] Regnans in Excelsis, Papal Encyclicals. <https://www.papalencyclicals.net/pius05/p5regnans.htm>
164. [S] Muller 2017, Studies in Church History. <https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/studies-in-church-history/article/transmitting-and-translating-the-excommunication-of-elizabeth-i/9AF60A76430F217253D0C482D45B01AF>
165. [R] Parker, The Past. <https://the-past.com/feature/why-the-armada-failed/>
166. [P] GHDI, Defenestration of Prague. <https://germanhistorydocs.org/en/from-the-reformations-to-the-thirty-years-war-1500-1648/the-war-begins-the-defenestration-of-prague-may-1618>
167. [R] Britannica, Thirty Years' War. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Thirty-Years-War>
168. [R] Britannica, La Rochelle. <https://www.britannica.com/place/La-Rochelle>
169. [R] Britannica, Shimabara Rebellion. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Shimabara-Rebellion>
170. [R] MLIT, Shimabara text. <https://www.mlit.go.jp/tagengo-db/common/001563310.pdf>
171. [W] Tabi-Samurai-Japan. <https://en.tabi-samurai-japan.com/story/event/441/2/>
172. [R] Britannica, English Civil Wars. <https://www.Britannica.Com/event/English-Civil-Wars>
173. [P] Solemn League and Covenant, Gardiner. <https://constitution.org/1-History/eng/conpur058.htm>
174. [R] EBSCO, Solemn League and Covenant. <https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/history/solemn-league-and-covenant>
175. [R] Lenihan, Confederation of Kilkenny. <https://www.encyclopedia.com/international/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/confederation-kilkenny>
176. [S] Haller 1950, Church History. <https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/church-history/article/abs/word-of-god-in-the-new-model-army/9E9170DCDA93D9587575B1CD3A6F389D>
177. [S] Underdown, LRB review of Carlton. <https://www.lrb.co.uk/v15/n11/david-underdown/praising-god>
178. [W] Griffin, History Ireland letter. <https://www.originalsite.historyireland.com/?p=13086>
179. [R] Irish Times 2011. <https://www.irishtimes.com/news/1641-rebellion-massacre-reports-based-on-hearsay-study-shows-1.574938>
180. [P] Cromwell to Lenthall, 17 September 1649. <https://www.olivercromwell.org/wordpress/cromwell-to-speaker-lenthall-17-september-1649/>
181. [R] Walters Art Museum, MS W.916. <https://art.thewalters.org/detail/1276>
182. [R] Britannica, Old Believers. <https://www.britannica.com/topic/Old-Believers>
183. [R] Historic Environment Scotland, BTL5. <https://portal.historicenvironment.scot/designation/BTL5>
184. [R] Finnegan, Jacobites and Williamite Wars. <https://www.encyclopedia.com/international/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/jacobites-and-williamite-wars>
185. [R] Britannica, Camisard. <https://www.britannica.com/topic/Camisard>

### Colonial conquest and imperial wars

186. [W] Wikipedia, Conquest of the Canary Islands. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conquest_of_the_Canary_Islands>
187. [R] College of Charleston LDHI, Pope Nicolas V and the Portuguese. <https://ldhi.library.cofc.edu/exhibits/show/african_laborers_for_a_new_emp/pope_nicolas_v_and_the_portugu>
188. [R] WHE, Doctrine of Discovery. <https://www.worldhistory.org/Doctrine_of_Discovery/.md>
189. [P] Inter caetera, Papal Encyclicals. <https://www.papalencyclicals.net/alex06/alex06inter.htm>
190. [W] Wikipedia, Spanish Requirement of 1513. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Requirement_of_1513>
191. [R] WHE, Spanish Requirement. <https://www.worldhistory.org/Spanish_Requirement/.md>
192. [R] Lehigh University, History on Trial timeline. <https://history-on-trial.lib.lehigh.edu/trial/justification/newspain/time/>
193. [R] History Today, Valladolid debate. <https://www.historytoday.com/archive/months-past/valladolid-debate-rights-indigenous-people>
194. [R] Library of Congress Law blog, Doctrine of Discovery. <https://blogs.loc.gov/law/2023/07/doctrine-of-discovery-until-otherwise/>
195. [R] Seton Hall, Montesinos sermon. <https://www.shu.edu/documents/aretheynotmen.pdf>
196. [P] Sublimis Deus, Papal Encyclicals. <https://www.papalencyclicals.net/paul03/p3subli.htm>
197. [P] Vatican News, Joint Note on the Doctrine of Discovery (official Vatican outlet reporting the Joint Note). <https://www.vaticannews.va/en/vatican-city/news/2023-03/vatican-formally-repudiates-doctrine-of-discovery.html>
198. [R] WHE, Prince Henry the Navigator. <https://www.worldhistory.org/Prince_Henry_the_Navigator/.md>
199. [W] Stoneking 2009, student thesis (student thesis). <https://teamsocialstudies.media.uconn.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/47/2021/04/The-Decline-of-the-Tainos-1492-1542_-A-Re-Vision-1.pdf>
200. [R] AHA, Religious Conflicts in the Conquest of Mexico. <https://www.historians.org/resource/religious-conflicts-in-the-conquest-of-mexico/>
201. [P] Bernal Díaz, ch. XXXV (primary text on a weak host). <https://www.latinamericanstudies.org/cempoala.htm>
202. [R] Christian History, The Christian Conquerors (confessional popular magazine). <https://www.christianhistoryinstitute.org/magazine/article/christian-conquerors>
203. [W] Flags of the World, Cortés's banner. <https://crwflags.com/FOTW/FLAGS/mx_1521.html>
204. [R] PBS, Conquistadors: Pizarro. <https://www.pbs.org/conquistadors/pizarro/pizarro_g00.html>
205. [R] Catholic Encyclopedia, Vicente de Valverde (1909-1912 Catholic Encyclopedia; dated and denominational). <https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/15265a.htm>
206. [R] Met Museum, Heilbrunn Timeline. <https://www.metmuseum.org/toah/ht/08/cana.html>
207. [W] Wikipedia, Mixtón War. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mixt%C3%B3n_War>
208. [S] Poole 1965, The Americas. <https://core-prod.cambridgecore.org/core/journals/americas/article/war-by-fire-and-blood-the-church-and-the-chichimecas-1585/83FE1CD6C01276970292F1480481F3CA>
209. [R] LOC Country Study, Philippines. <https://countrystudies.us/philippines/4.htm>
210. [W] Wikipedia, Castilian War. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castilian_War>
211. [W] New World Encyclopedia, Ahmad ibn Ibrahim. <https://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Ahmad_ibn_Ibrihim_al-Ghazi>
212. [W] Wikipedia, Russian conquest of Siberia. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_conquest_of_Siberia>
213. [S] Tuininga, OUPblog. <https://blog.oup.com/2025/01/the-massacre-at-fort-mystic-and-the-puritan-wars-of-the-lord>
214. [R] EBSCO, Battle of Mbwila. <https://ebsco.com/research-starters/military-history-and-science/battle-mbwila>
215. [R] Britannica, Pueblo Rebellion. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Pueblo-Rebellion>
216. [W] Wikipedia, Goa Inquisition. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goa_Inquisition>
217. [W] Wikipedia, Massacres in the Greek War of Independence. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacres_in_the_Greek_War_of_Independence>
218. [W] Wikipedia, Circassian genocide. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circassian_genocide>
219. [R] Britannica, Taiping Rebellion. <https://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/580815/Taiping-Rebellion>
220. [W] Wikipedia, Taiping Rebellion. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiping_Rebellion>
221. [R] Britannica, Charles George Gordon. <https://www.britannica.com/biography/Charles-George-Gordon>
222. [R] Britannica, Crimean War. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Crimean-War>
223. [R] Menning, Encyclopedia of Modern Europe. <https://encyclopedia.com/history/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/russo-turkish-war>
224. [W] Timewise Traveller. <https://www.timewisetraveller.co.uk/russo.html>
225. [R] LOC Country Study, Uganda. <https://countrystudies.us/uganda/5.htm>
226. [R] Britannica, Buganda. <https://www.britannica.com/place/Buganda>
227. [R] HistoryNet, Lacey on Omdurman. <https://www.historynet.com/what-we-learned-from-omdurman/>
228. [R] Royal Collection Trust, Gordon memorial service. <https://col.rct.uk/collection/407433/the-memorial-service-for-general-gordon-4-september-1898>
229. [R] Britannica, Boxer Rebellion. <https://www.britannica.com/event/Boxer-Rebellion>

### 1900 to November 2026

230. [S] Nilsson and Svensson 2018, Political Violence at a Glance. <https://politicalviolenceataglance.org/2018/05/23/what-we-know-and-dont-know-about-religious-civil-wars/>
231. [S] RELAC dataset record, JCR 2018. <https://relbib.de/Record/1577722876/Description>
232. [S] Toft 2021, PRIO. <https://www.prio.org/publications/13045>
233. [R] Americas Quarterly, Kloppe-Santamaría and Young. <https://americasquarterly.org/article/the-long-shadow-of-mexicos-war-over-catholicism/>
234. [W] El Imparcial column (title-level only). <https://www.elimparcial.com/tij/columnas/2026/08/01/cien-anos-de-la-cristiada-1926-2026/>
235. [R] Encyclopaedia Judaica, Iron Guard. <https://www.encyclopedia.com/reference/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/iron-guard>
236. [W] Spain Then and Now. <https://www.spainthenandnow.com/spanish-history/civil-war-and-the-catholic-church>
237. [R] Jewish Virtual Library, Jasenovac. <https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jasenovac-camp>
238. [S] Tufts WPF, Mass Atrocity Endings. <https://sites.tufts.edu/atrocityendings/?p=52>
239. [S] Omenka 2010, Journal of African History. <https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-african-history/article/abs/blaming-the-gods-christian-religious-propaganda-in-the-nigeriabiafra-war/AB81B380010028B6656AFB0D53612B59>
240. [R] Britannica, Nigerian civil war. <https://www.britannica.com/topic/Nigerian-civil-war>
241. [S] Lutterworth Press, Christian and Cultural Warfare in Rhodesia, ch. 1. <https://www.lutterworth.com/wp-content/uploads/extracts/christian-warfare-ch1.pdf>
242. [R] CAIN, Sutton Index. <https://cain.ulster.ac.uk/sutton/book>
243. [R] UP Diliman, Manili massacre. <https://oica.upd.edu.ph/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/02_UPDOR2024_Manili_Massacre.pdf>
244. [W] Wikipedia, Ilaga. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilaga>
245. [R] MERIP, primer on Lebanon's war. <https://merip.org/1990/01/primer-lebanons-15-year-war-1975-1990/>
246. [R] Encyclopedia.com, Sabra and Shatila. <https://encyclopedia.com/international/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/sabra-and-shatila>
247. [R] GlobalSecurity, NSCN. <https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/para/nscn.htm>
248. [R] Telangana Today, 15 October 2026. <https://telanganatoday.com/editorial-fresh-hope-for-naga-settlement>
249. [W] Wikipedia, NLFT. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Liberation_Front_of_Tripura>
250. [S] Allen 1991, Africa. <https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/africa/article/abs/understanding-alice-ugandas-holy-spirit-movement-in-context/DE89E3724443D29715DE5303EC10CE5B>
251. [R] IWG-LRA Diagnostic Study, World Bank. <https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/298391468148513539/pdf/651970WP0LRA0d00Box361556B00PUBLIC0.pdf>
252. [S] LUCAS Leeds, review of The LRA: Myth and Reality. <https://lucas.leeds.ac.uk/review/the-lords-resistance-army-myth-and-reality/>
253. [R] Gulf Times/AFP, UN report 2013. <https://www.gulf-times.com/story/353445/konys-lra-has-killed-more-than-100000-un>
254. [R] Invisible Children, The LRA's Final Chapter (NGO with its own advocacy history). <https://invisiblechildren.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/The-LRAs-Final-Chapter-September-2025.pdf>
255. [R] GlobalSecurity, ICC release reprint (reprint of the ICC press release). <https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/news/2025/11/mil-251106-icc01.htm>
256. [S] Goyushov, CNRS Observatoire des religions. <https://obsreligion.cnrs.fr/?p=2209>
257. [W] Christianity Today, September 2023 (title-level only). <https://www.christianitytoday.com/news/2023/september/nagorno-karabakh-war-artsakh-armenia-christian-advocacy.html>
258. [S] New Republic, Deák on Sells. <https://newrepublic.com/article/63709/god-their-sides>
259. [R] IPS, 2009. <https://www.ipsnews.net/?p=38217>
260. [R] USHMM, Srebrenica. <https://www.ushmm.org/confront-genocide/cases/bosnia-herzegovina/srebrenica/violence>
261. [R] Dawn/AFP 2007. <https://www.dawn.com/news/252819/97-000-killed-in-bosnian-war-study>
262. [P] NPR, Rudolph statement. <https://www.npr.org/2005/04/14/4600480/full-text-of-eric-rudolphs-confession>
263. [R] Herald-Standard/AP 2003. <https://www.heraldstandard.com/news/2003/feb/13/after-okc-bombing-fbi-found-link-to-group/>
264. [R] Al Jazeera 2012. <https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2012/3/28/christian-militia-acquitted-of-sedition-in-us>
265. [R] Dawn 2004. <https://www.dawn.com/news/398257/bush-regrets-invoking-crusade-after-911>
266. [R] SPLC Intelligence Report 2011 (advocacy NGO). <https://www.splcenter.org/get-informed/intelligence-report/browse-all-issues/2011/fall/christian-crusader>
267. [R] The Week, Breivik roundup. <https://theweek.com/articles/482714/terrorism-anders-breivik-christian>
268. [R] Al Jazeera 2020. <https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/12/8/new-zealand-2>
269. [R] CBS News. <https://www.cbsnews.com/news/new-zealand-shooting-gunman-rifles-white-supremacist-symbols-memes>
270. [R] MaltaToday. <https://www.maltatoday.com.mt/news/national/93667/malta_1565_inscription_on_terror_attack_rifle_shows_how_great_siege_is_appropriated_by_far_right>
271. [R] CSIS, 19 May 2026. <https://www.csis.org/analysis/san-diego-mosque-shooting-marks-deadly-first-united-states>
272. [R] Lado, Wilson Center 2014. <https://www.wilsoncenter.org/blog-post/what-is-religious-about-the-conflict-in-central-african-republic>
273. [R] Amnesty UK. <https://www.amnesty.org.uk/central-african-republic-crisis-ethnic-cleansing>
274. [R] USHMM, CAR. <https://www.ushmm.org/fr/genocide-prevention/countries/central-african-republic/political-and-ethnic-violence>
275. [R] HRW World Report 2026, CAR. <https://www.hrw.org/fr/world-report/2026/country-chapters/central-african-republic>
276. [R] UN News, February 2026. <https://news.un.org/en/story/2026/02/1167036>
277. [R] HRW 2018. <https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/06/28/nigeria-rising-toll-middle-belt-violence>
278. [R] ICG testimony 2017. <https://humanrightscommission.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/humanrightscommission.house.gov/files/documents/EJ%20Hogendoorn%20Testimony-%20ICG.pdf>
279. [R] Al Jazeera, 31 October 2025. <https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/10/31/trump-places-nigeria-on-watch-list-over-claims-of-anti-christian-violence>
280. [R] PBS/AP. <https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/u-s-launches-strike-against-islamic-state-forces-in-nigeria-trump-says>
281. [W] CSI-USA (advocacy; title-level only). <https://csi-usa.org/fulani-militants-kill-20-christians-in-nigerias-middle-belt-in-one-week/>
282. [W] AP via KSAT, February 2021 (title-level only). <https://www.ksat.com/news/world/2021/02/18/horrible-witnesses-recall-massacre-in-ethiopian-holy-city/>
283. [R] The National, January 2023. <https://thenationalnews.com/world/africa/2023/01/16/tigray-death-toll-could-be-as-high-as-600000-african-union-envoy-says>
284. [R] RNS/AP, 27 September 2022. <https://religionnews.com/2022/09/27/moscow-patriarch-russian-war-dead-have-their-sins-forgiven/>
285. [R] Atlantic Council, April 2024 (think-tank with pro-Ukraine editorial stance). <https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/ukrainealert/russian-orthodox-church-declares-holy-war-against-ukraine-and-west/>
286. [R] Moscow Times, February 2025 content (URL dated 2026, content from February 2025). <https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2026/07/23/training-the-warriors-of-victory-russian-orthodox-church-marks-3-years-of-war-in-ukraine>
287. [R] Moscow Times, February 2025 (URL dated 2026, content from February 2025). <https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2026/08/05/russian-patriarch-mocks-priest-for-questioning-churchs-patriotism>
288. [R] Church Times, 6 March 2026. <https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2026/13-march/news/world/russian-orthodox-leader-calls-on-russia-to-go-further-in-war-with-ukraine>

### Casualty figures, historiography and source criticism

289. [W] Catholic Answers, The Massacre of Jerusalem. <https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/the-massacre-of-jerusalem>
290. [W] Bede's Journal blog, on Pinker. <https://bedejournal.blogspot.com/2011/11/pinker-tackles-albigensian-crusade.html>
291. [S] Barber, via Medievalists.net. <https://www.medievalists.net/2013/09/the-albigensian-crusades-wars-like-any-other/>
292. [W] Holt, Death estimates for the Crusades (credentialled crusade historian's blog summarising published scholarship). <https://apholt.com/2019/01/30/death-estimates-for-the-crusades/>
293. [W] Holt, Casualty rates for First Crusade participants (credentialled crusade historian's blog summarising published scholarship). <https://apholt.com/2019/02/19/modern-scholars-on-the-casualty-rates-for-participants-of-the-first-crusade/>
294. [R] UCL Geography, Great Dying. <https://www.ucl.ac.uk/geography/news/2019/feb/great-dying-1492-led-lower-co2-and-cooler-planet>
295. [W] Wikipedia, Population history of the Indigenous peoples of the Americas. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_history_of_the_Indigenous_peoples_of_the_Americas>
296. [S] McCaa 1995, University of Minnesota. <https://users.pop.umn.edu/~rmccaa/noncuant/democat1.htm>
297. [S] Stanford working paper on pandemics in Mexico. <https://web.stanford.edu/~saumitra/papers/Pandemics_and_Economic_Resilience_in_Mexico_wp.pdf>
298. [R] Renick, Christian Century 2010. <https://christiancentury.org/print/pdf/node/28626>
299. [R] LRB review of Tyerman, God's War. <https://www.lrb.co.uk/v29/n23/jl-nelson/eastern-promises>
300. [R] McBain, Cairo Review. <https://www.thecairoreview.com/book-reviews/fields-of-blood/>
301. [R] Howell, Christian Century 2012. <https://christiancentury.org/print/pdf/node/29540>
